Take the 2-minute tour ×
Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I can't seem to find any information anywhere about the speed of the GregTech advanced pump. Considering that it is constructed from 4 BuildCraft Pumps and consumes quite a bit more energy, it seems like it should be an improvement in some way. The only information I have been able to find is about secondary improvements:

The biggest advantage over the regular Pump is that it removes both source blocks and flowing liquid, making the pumping less laggy. It also covers a much larger distance and depth.

(Source: http://ftbwiki.org/Advanced_Pump)

What about the actual speed of pumping, y'know, the whole point of a pump? When I test it on a server, I can see it pumping about 1-2 buckets per second with a dedicated MFE. This makes no sense. Is the much cheaper BuildCraft Pump (which can pump up to 1/t, or 20/second) actually the better pump?

share|improve this question
2  
Not causing lag is a huge advantage. It means you can pump the Nether for geothermal power without killing the server. –  SevenSidedDie Jun 10 '13 at 15:44
    
buildcraft pump has a large delay when it needs to move down a layer I don't know if the adv. pump has that as well –  ratchet freak Jun 10 '13 at 15:47
    
@SevenSidedDie: Caring about the server for a 2000% loss in pumping efficiency is a really really hard bargain... –  mellamokb Jun 10 '13 at 16:03
    
Well, maybe the advanced pump counts non-source blocks as a bucket? –  Jeffrey Lin Jun 10 '13 at 16:03
5  
Not when you can be kicked or banned for pumping the Nether. Most FTB servers have rules about not pumping the Nether ever – it's that bad for the server. Any pump is better than being banned and having no pump, right? This is the entire reason for the pump's existence. It's also the reason for the Magma Crucible's existence. It's not for player convenience, it's for not bringing servers to their knees. –  SevenSidedDie Jun 10 '13 at 16:15

1 Answer 1

up vote 35 down vote accepted
+100

In the beginning there was BuildCraft, and IndustrialCraft2, and the players had pumps and generators and lo, it was good.

Then the Nether tempted some. The vast lakes of lava were pumped and fed into the hungry maws of geothermal generators. For a time all was well, until more than one player decided to pump the Nether for power. The flowing lava and the many flow recalculations per second caused the server to flail and gnash its teeth, and there was much wailing and cries of "Why is the server so #&*$ing laggy? This server sucks!" The server ops wept for their children even as they banned pumping lava in the Nether, knowing they had no choice, and there was much sadness.

The modders, in their wisdom, thought long about this tragedy. The players love the geothermal generators, they said amongst themselves, but it causes much distress to the servers and the players cannot use their beloved pumps. What to do? So Thermal Expansion added the Magma Crucible so that there would be a source of lava without needing pumps and the flow blocks the pumps begat.

All was well for a time. But players still, in their newbness, pumped the Nether and had to be explained the uses and virtues of the Magma Crucible. And players, in their leetness, discovered that the Magma Crucible could generate free energy in the right configurations, and there were those that lamented the loss of the beloved Nether pumping stations and looked upon the vast burning lakes with longing, and some fell to temptation and were banned. The forums overflowed with cries for this injustice to be fixed and the Nether to be returned to its natural place as a source of geothermal power.

Greg heard the cries of the fallen, and held them to his bosom and gave them succor. "Here, give me your IC2 pumps and your BC pumps (but speak not to me of the RedPower pumps, for they are an abomination unto me). Give me your pumps, and take from me the Advanced Pump. Take this, my gift, and pump the Nether! It will pump more slowly, but while its pace be tempered, it will drain the vast lakes of lava without creating flow blocks, and lo, it will be no laggier than a quarry for it will merely remove blocks and cause no recalculations! Rejoice, for I am thy salvation!"

And the players beheld the Advanced Pump, and the scales fell from the eyes of some and they saw it was good. Those who knew of the old wailing and gnashing of teeth, and who followed the mystic movements of the mod developers saw what Greg had done and saw the wisdom. They could pump the Nether on shared servers, or run multiple pumps in their private games, and they would no longer see only a slideshow. There were players though who were but babes in arms when Nether pumping was learned to be nefarious and evil, and they looked upon the gift of the Advanced Pump and in their arrogance spat upon the ground and bit their thumbs in contempt.

Thus was confusion and disarray born. Greg bowed his head in sadness, but took comfort in the joy that he brought to the enlightened few. He knew this was the way of things, as he was already no stranger to the jibes of his detractors. He smiled his secret smile and turned his eyes from the confused and angry players, and basked in the love of those who understood him.

And so it was, and so it shall be again, for time is but an ever-turning wheel.

This is but a story, but in it there is the seeds of truth. Remember it and tell it to your children and your children's children, so that our people will remember and always walk in the light.

share|improve this answer
1  
While this answer is amazing, OP asks of speed, so throw that in somewhere. –  Batophobia Jun 10 '13 at 17:04
1  
@DavidStarkey Since the OP has already got their own speed numbers by pumping, I figured that repeating that wasn't necessary. What they're really asking (despite the majority of the question) is what the hell the Advanced Pump is for when it's slower than the regular pump, so I answered that. EDIT: Bah, you're right, it's better to acknowledge that it is slower. Done. :) –  SevenSidedDie Jun 10 '13 at 17:14
1  
This is the most entertaining answer I've ever read on the site to date. One of the few instances I truly wish I could give more than one +1 –  Ender Jun 10 '13 at 18:58
    
@SevenSidedDie You made me read it twice just to make sure it was in there. You clever devil. –  Batophobia Jun 10 '13 at 19:08
1  
I'm considering a bounty for this answer. It's amazing. –  Jeffrey Lin Jun 11 '13 at 19:41

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.