Take the 2-minute tour ×
Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've read the OpenTTD wiki page for a few times, but I don't really get it very well.

I usually use the 4th and 6th, but I'm not really sure what each of them does. And what are those things above the semaphores?

I have to note that I'm using signals a lot, but sometimes trains just get stuck and I fix it by randomly switching to other signals.

Can someone explain me train signals quick and easy?

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

up vote 25 down vote accepted

There are six different types of signals you can use, and can be used as two-way signals for tracks meant to go both ways, or one-way signals for tracks meant to go in only a single direction.

enter image description hereenter image description hereBlock Signals: These separate track parts into "blocks", which can contain only a single train per block. These blocks can be as large as you want, or as small. For efficiency, you'll want them roughly 10 blocks long. Less if the average train size is smaller.

If a train hits a block signal that already has a train, it will be stopped, and wait for the track to clear before proceeding. If for some reason a train hits the wrong side of a block signal, it will stop and turn around, as it thinks it's going the wrong way down the track.


Pre-signals need a bit of explanation before telling you how they work. They work like block signals, so they divide the track into blocks, but take their input from signals further down the line. They're really meant for one-way tracks, so I wouldn't recommend using them for two-way tracks. I'll explain how they work, and then afterwards how you can use them in combination.

enter image description hereenter image description hereEntry Pre-Signals: These signals work in tandem with Exit Pre-Signals. They're meant for one-way tracks that split into two or more paths. You place an Entry signal before the split. The closer you place it to the split, the less time the block will be in use.

enter image description hereenter image description hereExit Pre-Signals: Place these after the track splits. One on each track. Ideally right after, to minimize the amount of time the block remains in use. They function exactly like Block Signals, and "reserve" the block after the signal for a single train. If the block is open, they display a green light/bar is up.

Now, the point of the Entry and Exit Pre-Signals is for efficient pathfinding. As long as a single Exit Pre-Signal is green, the Entry Signal is green. Every single Exit Signal has to be red for the Entry to be red. This differs from Block Signals by one critical difference; trains are kinda stupid. Take a look at this picture:

Station with Block Signals

This is using Block Signals. Note that both stations are occupied by trains. Since the block right before the station (where the split is) was free, the block signal before the split let the train in, right before the station. This means it has to wait until the train directly in front of it moves out of the station before it can continue. The top train could leave, and the train waiting for a berth wouldn't budge. It's stuck, and will hold up the entire track until the bottom train moves.

Station with Pre Signals

But if you use the Pre-Signals, the train waits before the split. That means as soon as either station track is clear, it can advance, and won't necessarily wait for the bottom track. It'll be first come, first serve.

enter image description hereenter image description hereCombo Pre-Signals: These work like both Entry and Exit Pre-Signals. They're meant to be used if you have a large number of splits in a short area. You'd use an Entry before any of the splits happen, Exit Signals after all the splits are done, and Combos in between. This picture shows a good example of when to use Combo Pre-Signals:

Combo Pre Signals At one track, there's an Entry Signal, getting it's signal from the two Combo Signals right after it, and they, in turn, are getting their signals from each of their two Exit Signals. By layering it like this, the train is still held up before committing to any track that might cause it to rely on a train to leave the station.

Note that you can just use entry and exit pre-signals as well; remove the Combo signals, and it will function just the same. For the most part, there's no real reason to use Combo Signals.


Path signals are exclusive to OpenTTD; they were never in Transport Tycoon Deluxe. What they do is allow a train to "reserve" a section of track before it gets to it. If it succeeds in reserving the track, it will use it, even if another train is inside the "block". This picture does a pretty good job of explaining it:

Path Signals

If you were only using block signals, the second train would be held up until the first train clears the junction, even if it's not using the bottom lane. With path signals, the second train won't even slow down; it succeeded in reserving the bottom lane, so away it goes.

There are some more examples for path signals at the wiki you linked to. This is just meant as a general use reference.

share|improve this answer
3  
WOW ! Thanks a lot. I now understand how all of them work. You explained way better than the wiki. –  Alex Dumitru Jul 23 '13 at 2:05
5  
I just realized how magnificently thought through the TTD signalling was. –  user98085 Jul 23 '13 at 13:14
    
"Note that you can just use entry and exit pre-signals as well; remove the Combo signals, and it will function just the same. For the most part, there's no real reason to use Combo Signals." - doesn't adding them increase throughput? If two trains closely follow one another, the second train will only have to wait until the first train clears the main split block, not the entire complex of splits. –  Jan Dvorak Jan 20 at 6:35
    
@JanDvorak The Combo Signals would speed up the track selection slightly, but not overly so. –  Frank Jan 20 at 21:26
1  
Is there any reason not to use path signals for everything all the time? –  toryan Jun 11 at 19:43

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.