Take the 2-minute tour ×
Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've gone through my share of Binding of Isaac playthroughs, and almost always bother with looting challenge rooms, which in turn has me fighting three waves of enemies.

Having done this enough times, some of the waves spawned in the various challenge rooms seem suspiciously repetitive. Is there any sort of randomness to the enemies spawned, or are they, in fact, set?

share|improve this question
    
I've noticed the same. I'd probably say that it worked somewhat like the room designs - there's a load of pre-made patterns, and one of them is randomly selected for each encounter. –  Kristian Fenn Nov 2 '11 at 12:30
add comment

1 Answer

up vote 5 down vote accepted

After several careful playthroughs taking notes, I believe I can answer my own question.

Enemy waves are indeed set, but this is only 95% accurate. The enemy waves for each zone (Basement, Caves, The Depths, etc.) are always the same (two for each zone, other than basement, where I've only ever seen a challenge room on the second floor and Sheol, which only has one floor). However, there is no set association between floor and wave, meaning that if we have floors 1 and 2 and waves A and B, the association of floors to waves could be either 1-A, 2-B or 1-B, 2-A (though this loose association might be new in light of the Halloween update, as prior to this I've have always had the same wave on the same floor in the same zone). So why 95%? It's almost always 1-A and 2-B from my experience (even after the update).

So here are the waves for each zone (check the wiki for monster and boss names):

  • Basement:
    • Wave A:
      1. 5 x Fly (the blinking red ones, not the docile black ones)
      2. 5 x Pooter
      3. 5 x Gaper (pretty sure either kind can spawn, usually the ones with shut eyes)
  • Caves:
    • Wave A:
      1. 5 x Charger
      2. 4 x Globin (usually the slow kind, but fast ones can spawn)
      3. 4 x Maw (either kind, but usually 3 white and 1 red)
    • Wave B:
      1. 5 x Spity
      2. 3 x Hive
      3. 3 x Host (both kinds, but usually it's 3 armored ones)
  • The Depths:
    • Wave A:
      1. 4 x Baby
      2. 5 x Hopper
      3. 4 x Knight (the faster version new to the Halloween update can also spawn)
    • Wave B:
      1. 3 x Vis
      2. 4 x Leaper
      3. 4 x Globin (always the fast ones, as far as I have seen)
  • The Womb:
    • Wave A:
      1. 3 x Larry Jr. (each just a head and one segment)
      2. 1 x Chub
      3. 2 x Monstro
    • Wave B:
      1. 1 x Fistula
      2. 1 x Loki
      3. 1 x Chub
  • Sheol
    • See below

Seeing how Sheol is rather new and also a pain to walk around needlessly, I've only been to the challenge room one time. I got The Womb's wave A, and if I had to guess you simply get one of The Womb's waves. If I find out otherwise I'll be sure to update this answer (and feel free to shed some light on this point yourselves).

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.