Take the 2-minute tour ×
Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've been looking for weapons that are upgrades from the default weapons in TF2.

Ex. Third Degree. It's techinically an upgrade since there are no downsides and it hits players via Medigun beams.

Are there any other weapons like this?

share|improve this question
add comment

5 Answers 5

up vote 9 down vote accepted
+100

Assuming "upgrade" means "has no downsides and additional non-cosmetic upsides", the current list would be this:

  • Third Degree (same as Fire Axe, but also damages everything else connected by medigun beams)
  • Solemn Vow (same as Bonesaw, but also allows visibility of enemy health panels)
  • Hotrod (same as other hats, but due to a bug, if a Spy's disguise is wearing one and he's holding a Sapper, it'll flip over his face and expose him to attentive players)

There are not currently any other pure upgrades in the game - any weapons that seem so are either purely cosmetic differences (Golden Wrench's Australiumization effect), replace a weapon with a support item of uncomparably different functionality (Sandvich, Gunboats), or have an upside that significantly outclasses the downside (Amputator having a healing taunt is much more important than the 20% damage reduction, which while probably technically an "upgrade" I don't think is the purpose of this question).

share|improve this answer
    
Huh, I did not realize that they nerfed the Amputator's damage. Have they done the same with the previously far-overpowered Holiday Punch? –  Zibbobz Jan 7 at 15:23
2  
No the Holiday Punch remains unchanged; its only downside is still "crits deal no damage". –  Toomai Jan 7 at 19:09
add comment

Nearly all weapons that are not "default" either have a penalty attached to them, or change drastically the nature of that weapon slot. So items that are nothing but an 'upgrade' are very rare.

Here are, as far as I know, the items that exclusively add to a "stock" item's ability, with no downside or change in functionality.

  • Fire Axe > Third Degree - Adds "shared damage" between targets attached by medic beam.
  • Bonesaw > Amputator - Adds healing taunt that heals multiple team members at once.
  • Fists > Holiday Punch - Causes target to laugh when struck from the back (stunning effect)
  • Bat > Fish? - Special Kill Tracking (You might consider this an upgrade, or you might consider it a downgrade that reveals your location)

Note: Amputator and Holiday Punch both have downsides. The Amputator does -20% damage, and the Holiday Punch does no crit damage.

share|improve this answer
1  
It does crit, it just doesn't do damage. –  lumbricus lubricant Jan 11 at 2:51
add comment

There are only 2 direct upgrades in the game.

The Third Degree: With no downsides, the only upside is that this weapon hits enemies that are connected through a Medi-Beam.

The Solem Vow: With no downsides, the only upside is that this weapon shows you the HP of enemies that you are aiming at.

Weapons such as Ali Babas Wee Booties, Targe n' Charge, Kritzkrieg, RazorBack, ect, ect are side grades. Even though they have no downsides (stat wise), they do take up a slot. The Booties take place of your Grenade Launcher, and the shields take up your sticky launcher. Same with the Sniper Backpacks, Soldier Boots, and Heavy Food. The Kritzkrieg (with no down stats) is a side grade as well. It turns your invulnerability into insta crits. The equalizer/escape plan are great melee weapons, but they prevent being healed (and the escape plan makes it so you take Mini-Crits while out), so they are not upgrades.

I hope this cleared up the above answers.

share|improve this answer
    
I'm pretty sure the Amputator has a downside. –  lumbricus lubricant Jan 9 at 23:27
    
But it is a plus with no stat downs. –  Shadow Zorgon Jan 10 at 1:43
    
-20% damage penalty isn't really a plus :C –  lumbricus lubricant Jan 10 at 7:13
    
They did that?!? –  Shadow Zorgon Jan 10 at 21:10
    
I fixed it, it has been a while since I owned one –  Shadow Zorgon Jan 10 at 21:11
add comment

Almost all of the weapons you can drop or craft are upgrades from the default weapons. The dev team has always tried to do a great job in balancing the power of your enemy-killers. That's why most of them have a "malus": you have to weight, considering your playstyle, the great things that your weapons do and consider if those outshine the bad part.

The weapons that don't have a red text usually are made that way because they have a way of functioning that completely substitute the normal behaviour of the weapon for that slot. Take for example the "shoes" for the soldier or the demo (Mantreads, Gunboats, Bootlegger...): to use those you have to completely give up the secondry weapon slot, getting a passive bonus instead. The same applies for the shields for the demo or the sniper. Medic's alternative healing guns completely substitute the Overcharge mechanics. Amputator's "bonus" requires a taunt, that effectively makes you lose control of your character while executing it.

Third degree's bonus? It's almost always a suicide getting with a Pyro in melee range of someone getting healed by a Medic.

You have a great freedom of choice and the official wiki can be a good place to get a good idea of what can be a good upgrade.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Have a look on the official wiki http://wiki.teamfortress.com/ Most of weapons are "upgraded" in TF2, we can't list all of them here. If you're looking only for "full bonus weapons" (which is not really true), here's your list :

  • Gunboats
  • Mantreads
  • Equalizer
  • Ali Baba's Wee Booties
  • Bootlegger
  • Chargin' Targe
  • Splendid Screen
  • Dalokohs's Bar
  • Fishcake
  • Apoco's Fists
  • Pomson 6000
  • Golden Wrench (the only one truly upgraded)
  • Krietzkrieg
  • Amputator
  • Solemn Vow
  • Razorback
  • Darwin's Danger Shield
  • Cloak & Dagger
  • Saxxy
share|improve this answer
2  
Kritzkrieg is completely different - neither an upgrade nor a downgrade. You replace the immunity übercharge with a 100% crit übercharge. –  ThiefMaster May 15 '12 at 9:00
1  
Even the Golden Wrench is not technically an upgrade - its stats are identical to the regular wrench, it "only" applies a unique kill animation, a purely cosmetic effect. –  Hackworth May 15 '12 at 10:50
    
Ubersaw - within the competitive scene of tf2 all medics use ubersaws. –  Simon May 15 '12 at 11:52
1  
Simon: I don't know; in competitive, I doubt that a medic would be able to get close enough to a player to get a hit. Also (IMO), that kind of offensive behavior is not as helpful to the rest of the team. –  kuyan May 15 '12 at 22:46
    
Not only is this list incredibly out of date, several of these weapons are side-grades, not upgrades. There really ought to be a better list for this. –  Zibbobz Jan 7 at 14:31
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.