Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I have got about 5-7 vassals without fiefs, but with hight relation rate (about 60+ each). Should I give them fiefs or they won't leave me anyway? I have got 3-4 vassals with low relation rate (about 4-8) and if I start to giving aways fiefs I could lose relationship with them.

share|improve this question
up vote 1 down vote accepted

Politics in Calderia is very very tricky. There are benefits and drawbacks of doing either, and you should be very careful when granting fiefs as you can easily alienate a lot of your vassals if you give them out too fast.

Here are the things you have to consider:

  • Granting a fief to a certain lord will alienate all other lords who are not on friendly terms with the one who got the fief. Your relationship with all of these lords may drop by several points. Yet, giving a fief to a lord is not enough a big enough bump for him to overlook you giving a fief to two lords he despises.
  • Higher relationships with your lords will ensure that it's less likely for them to defect and cause you to lose a fief. So you always want to make sure your important fief holders for castles and towns have good relationships with you.
  • Before granting a fief, it helps if you talk to each lord to determine who they support. This is rather time consuming and annoying.
  • Try not to give a lord two fiefs on the opposite sides of the map. Most lords have a preferred 'home' and giving them a fief on the far side of the map means he'll most likely neglect one of them since he can only be one in place at a time.
  • Give the important fiefs (towns, castles) to lords with higher relationships and the villages to less dependable lords.
  • After granting a fief, spend some time patching up relationships with the other lords to keep their relationships up higher. Hosting a feast (only do this in times of peace) is a good way of mass bumping everyone's relations up by a point or two.

I prefer to stick to a small but highly dependent group of lords, but this leads to other issues as you expand in territory it becomes harder to patrol and defend your borders. The more lords you have, the more annoying it becomes, so the more time you'll have to spend patching up relationships.

share|improve this answer

First of all, use diplomacy mod instead of native. This allows you to set a policy which can affect relations with your vassals (both good and bad), this will make time your friend.

As to assigning them fiefs, each lord should have at LEAST have 1 fief; if they have no fiefs then their relations will keep dropping until they defect, even if the lord loves you when he joins.

As stated above, never give a lord 2 fiefs which are far away from each other, because the lord will neglect one of them.

And, as stated above, keep your castles and towns for good lords, these are the lords that have a high relationship with you without your active attempt to raise it. This depends on your own character and the way you rule your nation.

Example: if you have a very high honor, honorable lords will start liking you, even if they never met you. They still lose relations with you if you give them fiefs, but given enough time this problem fixes itself. Give your important fiefs to these lords as they are very unlikely to rebel.

Another "fix" for the problem, if you have lords with -1 or lower you can ask a friendly lady to send them a gift. It's very expensive, but it does do the trick.

-20 to 0 = unhappy, these lords are unlikely to respond to your orders, such as gathering the army or coming to a certain spot.

-100 to -20 = disgruntled, if this lad has an important fief you might want to make the first move, when they go below -20 there is a very real chance of them rebelling, the lower the relations the higher this chance. If they hold a castle or town, you lose this with all of the villages that come with it.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.