For example, can you get a gold shovel (by buying 50 fertilizer) before getting a silver shovel (donating 15 fossils)?


Yes, it is entirely possible, just as it has been in earlier Animal Crossing games.

There is a difference in how to obtain the tools of different levels, but you do not have to obtain them in any certain order.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.