After you kill the guard in the prologue, Michael literally says "You didn't have to to do that" and later in the game the number of bodies at the bank job is referenced. Is there an option not to kill the guard?

  • You could add to your question: "What would be the consequence when you kill or not the guard" :-)
    – Luc M
    Sep 28, 2013 at 18:39

3 Answers 3


It appears that you HAVE to take out the guard no matter what.

As shown on this website you have to take out the guard. So, it appears that he is just saying that "You didn't have to kill him" as a on the spot remark when there actually was no alternative.

Further proof is shown here:

Michael is held at gunpoint by a security guard who removed his mask covering his face and is later shot in the head by Trevor.

  • 3
    Neither of those sites is "proof"
    – boomstick
    Oct 2, 2013 at 12:22
  • @JonathanWakely "And is later shot in the head by Trevor". There's the proof. Oct 2, 2013 at 14:30
  • 6
    No, that's not proof, that just means someone played the game and did it the same way we did, by shooting him. I believe you have to kill him, but a statement on an unofficial wiki doesn't prove you can't do it another way. I could edit that wiki to say you can make Chop drive a car, that doesn't prove it's true.
    – boomstick
    Oct 2, 2013 at 14:51

I'm a little late, but being wrapped up in the Karma conspiracy, I wondered the same thing.. I tried multiple ways to get passed that prompt without killing that guard. If you shoot him in the leg, he falls but shoots Michael in the head. If you try to shoot his hand or gun, you end up shooting Michael in the head. I have a theory as to why you are forced to do this, but I'm very interested if anyone finds a way around it!


If you shoot the very tip of the gun then the guard will only graze Michele and as my Michele falls in pain you see him alive looking at the guard, but you still fail somehow even though everyone is alive

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .