0

I have a 3x3 column of up-down stairs that I've dug out, and accidentally broke through to the caverns before I was ready. In trying to block the bottom, I dug out the bottom set of up-down stairs and tried to replace them with an up stairs construction.

DF won't let me build a 3x3 up stair in the space; it says it's blocked. However, it does let me build a 2x3 stair and a 1x3 stair to fill the same space. Why?

z+1 is the level above the build issue where the last up/down stair (designation) is.. z is where the 2 up-stair constructions are (2x3 on top, 1x3 is the row on the bottom) and z-1 is cavern.

z+1      z       z-1
-----    --££-   .--  
-XXX%    £<<<%   -----
%XXX%    £<<<%   ,,',-
%XXX%    £<<<%   '𝓇-'-
%%%%%    ☼☼☼%%   ---.`
2
  • Mind providing some pictures of what you've got? Hard to know what we're dealing with without knowing what's on the 3 z-levels (level in question and +/- 1) – Raven Dreamer Dec 29 '13 at 20:19
  • Sure, as best I can. I can't figure out how to get an RTF dump of the map, so I've got to approximate with what I can type in. – mpounsett Dec 29 '13 at 20:50
1

After consulting your diagrams, it seems that you are building all of the staircases you want/need to, you just couldn't build them in a batch, correct?

If that's the case, then there are a few one-off issues that could have caused this -- trying to order the construction while the previous structures are still there; transient issues with claimed building materials being or not-being in the appropriate square.

In short; I'd not worry about it, as I don't think this is a common scenario to run into.

2
  • 1
    That's right. I was able to build a 2x3 and a 1x3, but not a 3x3; the 3x3 was marked as blocked. I couldn't figure out what was supposedly blocking it. – mpounsett Dec 29 '13 at 21:15
  • 1
    @mpounsett I think you need one accessible tile outside of any combined construction job - it acts like the mass of staircases is one building while placing it. – Brilliand May 16 '14 at 21:16
0

I would advise that you just build floors! A dwarf will end up stuck at the bottom but if you add another 1x1 up stair with a down stair above he will get back out of there. Replaing the Up/Downs with just Ups will stop walking creatures from coming in, but flying ones will go straight up!

3
  • You can't build floors without stairs in place because then there are no materials available (no way to carry them down). Leaving a single stair lets the materials down, but then that square isn't blocked against flying creatures. And it looks like you can't build a stair on top of a floor because the space is blocked. – mpounsett Dec 29 '13 at 21:14
  • That's why I said a guy would be left down there. You floor off the outside 8 stairs - the guy who floors off the final one gets stuck. Getting materials there in the first place is a non issue - if you've just dug the stairs, there will be stone lying around, if not, use a stockpile. Better than leaving the stairs open to flying invaders – Josh W Dec 29 '13 at 21:21
  • 1
    Up Stairs include a floor, so they're perfectly valid for blocking things off from below. – Raven Dreamer Dec 29 '13 at 22:33
0

I believe the issue is with carving/designating vs building/constructing. Since you already designated, or carved out the floor to make a up/down stairs you cannot designate/carve out a upstairs on that tile.

One of your options are to remove the stairs completely, then place a floor or up stairs through the build/construct command "b"-"C". If you do not have access then you need not designate another stairs next to your original 3x3 staircase to get there.

I always looked at a tile like this: It has a floor section and a block section. A up stair would have the floor in tact and a staircase in the block section. A downstairs is basically just a tile without a floor so it can reach the staircase below it. A up/down stairs have both a staircase and a hole in the floor.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.