5

My monster mob zoo is failing; I can't keep them from teleporting out. The photo shown is not one I have taken but it demonstrates what I am trying to do:

Not my photo

How do I keep my mobs from teleporting through glass? Note that I am using the PC version and am in creative mode.

| improve this question | |
  • to my knowledge the only mob which can teleport are Endermen, also the game mode shouldn't matter as they don't change how block works, it's just that you can place any block/item rather than craft it and destroy them with a single hit – Memor-X Jul 23 '14 at 1:31
  • 6
    I think what is probably happening here is the mobs are despawning. If you don't do something to prevent them from despawning, like use a name tag, then hostile mobs will despawn when there are no players within 32 blocks. – Unionhawk♦ Jul 23 '14 at 2:03
  • 1
    When I made a zoo I used iron bars, with stone slabs on top for shade, and had no problems. Unless you count the Ghast exhibit, since iron bars do not block fireballs. I also named every creature to make sure they never de-spawn. – Batophobia Jul 23 '14 at 14:24
  • @Batophobia Not to be too contradictory but that link to the page about iron bars in the wiki says "...iron bars are not destroyed by a Ghast's fireball, and since they block a Ghast's line of sight...". You're right about the naming though, name tags are the ultimate solution. – Pharap Jul 23 '14 at 15:15
  • 1
    @Pharap You are correct that Iron Bars are not destroyed by fireballs. What I meant was that fireballs would travel through the bars, unless an update fixed that. – Batophobia Jul 23 '14 at 15:19
7

As @Unionhawk said, your mobs are almost certainly de-spawning. This means they vanish from the world forever, like footprints in the sand. But as time goes by new mobs spawn, such is the circle of life.

In order to have a proper 'zoo' of mobs, you need to stop them de-spawning. In the case of Zombies, (as @MrLemon pointed out) simply throwing an item at them and letting them pick it up is enough to keep them spawned. However this only works for Zombies.

Thankfully, as of 1.6.1, there is an item designed to both name mobs and keep them spawned for good - the name tag. Name tags can be found naturally within chests that spawn in dungeons or (as of 1.7.2) by fishing.

If you're in creative you can pull one straight from the creative inventory, and if you have access to console commands (i.e. you allowed them in map options when creating the map) you can use this command:

/give <player> 421 <amount>

Where <player> is replaced with your minecraft name and <amount> is replaced by the number of items you want. For example I would type:

/give Pharap 421 1

which would give me a single name tag.

Alternatively (as pointed out by @SaintWacko) you can avoid specifying your name by typing this instead:

/give @p 421 1

Also note that an enderman is the only mob naturally capable of teleporting, thus even after naming one it is still capable of escaping. Also note that name tags do not stop mobs from dying, so try not to suffocate them or set any on fire.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    Sidenote: You should not use item IDs anymore, as they are being phased out in 1.8. Use minecraft:name_tag or just name_tag instead. – MrLemon Jul 23 '14 at 11:20
  • 1
    Also, a zombie that has picked up an item. So you can try throwing something at them as a "ghetto nametag", which is especially useful in survival, since real nametags are rare. – MrLemon Jul 23 '14 at 11:22
  • @MrLemon I know about them being phased out, but I'm not switching until they actually release 1.8 officially rather than just snapshots. I doubt they'll be releasing 1.8 officially for a few months yet. I shall +1 the note about the 'poor-man's nametag', but the question did state that this was in creative, which is the main reason I didn't put much emphasis on survival options. – Pharap Jul 23 '14 at 11:31
  • 2
    Man, that first sentence was meta – Mitch Jul 23 '14 at 12:28
  • 1
    Also, @p can be used to target yourself, so you don't have to type out your own name. – SaintWacko Jul 23 '14 at 14:39
2

It seems likely that you're not getting teleporting behavior out of your mobs. What you are more likely getting is pack-spawn behavior.

If you google "minecraft pack spawn" you'll get a hit on this page. Here's a quote from that site:

For each spawning cycle, one attempt is made to spawn a pack of mobs in each eligible chunk. A random location in the chunk is chosen to be the center point of the pack. For the pack to spawn at all, the center block must be water for water mobs and air for all other mobs. Note that in the latter case, it must actually be an air block. Any other block, even a non-colliding one, will prevent the entire pack from spawning. If the pack location is suitable, 12 attempts are made to spawn up to 4 mobs (8 for Wolves, 1 for Ghasts) within a 41×1×41 area centered at that block (that's a 41×41 square that is one block high). Mobs will spawn with the lowest part of their body inside this area. For each spawn attempt, a block location within the pack area is chosen at random. Though the pack area extends 21 blocks out from the center, the random location is heavily skewed toward the center of the pack. Approximately 85% of spawns will be within 5 blocks of the pack center, and 99% within 10 blocks of the center.

Now for a human-readable version of that information.

If your "cage" has spawnable space in it, then the pack spawn can result in mobs spawning within 10 blocks of that location, provided they are also valid spawnable space. (Also of note - the area surrounding the cage would need to be at the same y-level to result in pack spawning.)

That link above will also help you understand what constitutes spawnable space, but for your purposes you can probably think of it as a light-level issue. If you press F3 and look at the "bl:" part, that shows your the light level for the place you are currently standing. If that number is 7 or below, then the place you are standing is likely a valid spawn location. (There are other things to consider, but I'm assuming you are standing there and you are not on a slab.)

Essentially you have 2 or 3 options to avoid escaping attractions in your park;

  1. Light everything up above light level 7 (note: will not stop passive mobs from spawning)
  2. Place your "cages" at a different y level than everything else in the area.
  3. Otherwise make all surrounding space within 10 blocks (at the y-level of your cage floor) unspawnable.
| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.