7

After some time playing Omega Ruby and attempting to complete my Dex, I've noticed some substantial variability in the time it takes to produce an egg. It got me thinking - what actually determines the breeding time?

I've done some casual looking, but can't find too much on the subject - just some vague notions about compatibility and certain types taking longer. I haven't been able to accurately reproduce a breeding cycle, but I think I've determined a few factors that may influence it:

  • Day/night: breeding seems to take a LOT longer after the sun sets. When breeding for a specific nature, during the day I often fill my party with eggs before any of them hatch. When breeding the same pokemon into the night, though, I often hatch 2-3 before gaining another egg.
  • Held items: any incense-breeding to produce a baby pokemon seems to reliably take longer than breeding the pokemon itself.
  • Marathons: The breeding rate seems to change steadily the longer a certain pokemon is in the daycare. For some, the time seems to increase - for others (mostly starters), the eggs seem to come faster and faster. Not reliable.
  • Level: Higher-level pokemon seem to have a slightly higher average breeding time. Not reliable.
  • Evolution: Breeding an evolution vs a base (eg Blastoise vs a Squirtle) seems to increase the average breeding time in some cases. Not reliable.
  • Type: Type doesn't seem to affect breeding time at all. I've had dragon-types spit out a second egg faster than I could walk away, and I've had a Caterpie take literally 20 minutes to produce.
  • Rarity/Power: Very subjective/unreliable. The more powerful/difficult-to-obtain a pokemon is, the longer it seems to take to breed. I tried to benchmark this with a Kangaskhan, Metagross, Gloom, and Wurmple - the first two took considerably longer to produce than the second two. There are definite exceptions (see Caterpie above). This may also just be a function of level/evolution.

This is not a rigorous exploration by any means - I haven't timed cycles or anything. There's also the chance that it's 100% random and I'm basing conjecture on happenstance.

Can anyone tell me what factors actually influence breeding time?

  • After another week of breeding and observation, I've found day vs night has a measurable, reproducible effect on breeding rates - averaging about 1.7 times longer at night. Still possible this is random, but after a few dozen eggs from a few dozen pokemon, odds are very slim. – CodeMoose Dec 31 '14 at 15:20
5

The chance of an egg being produced is dependent on the Original trainer ID numbers and Species of the pokemon involved.

The day care Man can tell you how likely an egg is going to be generated after each set of 256 steps going on what he says.

Taken from Bulbapedia:

  • Same species, Different Original Trainer - "The two seem to get along very well" - 70% (88% with oval charm)
  • Same species, Same Original Trainer - "The two seem to get along" - 50% (80% with oval charm)
  • Different species, Different Original Trainer - "The two seem to get along" - 50% (80% with oval charm)
  • Different species, Same Original Trainer - "The two don't really seem to like each other very much." - 20% (40% with oval charm)
  • Different Egg Groups, same gender, or Undiscovered group - The two prefer to play with other Pokémon more than with each other. - 0%

That's all there is to it. It didn't need to change as the generations went on, they've just added more mechanics into it, like IV and nature breeding.

  • This does explain a few things, I never took OT vs Trades into account. Thanks for the answer! – CodeMoose Mar 21 '15 at 19:15
  • It's been the same way since gen 3, if not gen 2 as well – Force Gaia Mar 21 '15 at 19:16
0

According to Bulbapedia:

The chance of any two Pokémon producing an Egg is determined by their species (two Bulbasaur are the same species, while Bulbasaur and Ivysaur are not) and their Original Trainers.

When there are two compatible Pokémon in the Day Care, the game will periodically decide whether the Day-Care Man has found an Egg, with the chances depending on the compatibility of the two Pokémon. In Generation III and later, the game determines whether an Egg appears after every 256 steps the player takes.

It's just luck. Nothing else.

The only other factor known that affects getting an egg is Oval Charm, which increases the chance of getting an Egg.

  • That's all I was able to find too. It definitely explains part of the mechanic, but it seems wrong to believe that the breeding mechanic hasn't changed at all since Gen III - especially when everything else has changed so much. – CodeMoose Dec 31 '14 at 15:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.