So far, I've been living on the straight and narrow, not taking that which is not mine, and being a generally upstanding Sharkman.

But the longer I play this game, the more old habits cry out to me. RPG Kleptomania is setting in, and if it's not nailed down, well, by gum I'm going to take it!

Catch is of course, that some of the nice stuff that's not nailed down is in containers that, when moused over, display a red interaction icon, instead of the normal silver gauntlet. It appears that this indicates that the goods in question have an owner, who will be none to happy with my purloining of their pilferables.

However, I just took a fairly nice cape from such a container in the Black Hound Inn in Gilded Vale. The nameless NPC who shared a room with the chest in question - the presumptive owner - told me off briefly, but took no action against me.

At what point will my criminal ways catch up to me and get me in trouble? Is getting yelled at by NPCs with no actual plot or dialog value really the worst I can expect?

  • 1
    I stole a book somewhere in a house in gilded vale, the npc's immediately became hostile and I took a reputation penalty with the people of gilded vale..
    – Tsasken
    Mar 27, 2015 at 6:45
  • On two separate occasions in Defianca Bay I was also attacked at once for stealing. They were however combat-ready NPCs (knights and merceneries respectively), so that might be a factor. Someone should also screen for reputation effects (maybe town champion can steal to his heart content?).
    – Deltharis
    Mar 29, 2015 at 1:10

1 Answer 1


If you steal the item successfully whilst in stealth mode, there's no punishment. If you are caught, you may just get a talking to, or you may get a reputation loss through either the action or any combat that's initiated because you were caught. This can lead to the possibility of not being able to select certain special reputation dialogue options that can appear, if you're regarded poorly with the relevant faction.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .