8

Regenerating health on "Death March" difficulty can take a while if you have a rather big health pool and no perk to regenerate health (e.g. using Quen).

Apart from potions I use food to regenerate health. However, it can take quite a long time if I have to eat Dried Fruit And Nuts 5 times. I eat one, wait 5 seconds, open the inventory again (or use the quick slot) and wait 5 more seconds.

Therefore I'd like to know if vitality regeneration stacks by eating multiple foods.

For example (numbers not accurate):

  • I eat 1 "Dried Fruit and Nuts"
    • 100 vitality restored over 5 seconds.
  • I eat 2 "Dried Fruit and Nuts" then leave the inventory screen. What is the outcome?
    1. Regenerate 100 vitality over 5 seconds.
    2. Regenerate 200 vitality over 5 seconds.

Which way does it work? Assuming it works like 1. I would have to keep opening the menu, eating 1 piece of food, opening the menu again and eat the next. I don't like placing food in my two quick slots because I usually save those slots for my most important potions.


Edit 1:

After having a look at the question to which this question is flagged as a duplicate I concluded that there are contradictions on how the stacking works.

Two theories that need proof (proven in Edit 2):

  1. Vitality regeneration does stack, no matter what you eat/drink.
  2. Vitality regeneration only stacks if the foods consumed are not of the same type (e.g. 2 x Nuts do not stack, but 1 x cow milk + 1 x nuts will stack).

I will test this when I get home looking at the numbers (vitality information on the inventory screen).

Right now, everything points to theory 2 since theory 1 would make you invincible for a short time if you stuff 20 roasted chickens down Geralt's throat.


Edit 2:

I can confirm theory 2.

Eating one raw meat regenerated 508 hp over 5 seconds.

Eating one raw meat and one cow's milk added two regeneration indicators to the UI and regenerating 1432 hp over 30 seconds. The timer for raw meat ran 5 seconds while the cow's milk timer ran 30 seconds.

This also confirms that different foods have different intensities of regeneration. While raw meat regenerates 508 hp over 5 seconds, cow's milk regenerated 924 hp over 30 seconds.

Oddly, drinking cow's milk without eating at the same time regenerated 931 hp.

  • Raw meat: 508 hp
  • Cow's milk: 931 hp
  • 1 x raw meat + 1 x cow's milk: 1432 hp (instead of predicted 508 + 931 = 1439 hp)

I did the tests at level 30.

  • You'll also find some information in this related answer from me – Mad Scientist Sep 14 '15 at 10:00
  • The answer from @MadScientist is actually good and correct, I'd recommend to check that one out instead of the one which was marked as duplicate since its wrong. – Y U NO WORK Sep 14 '15 at 10:11
  • I can tell that it works like in edit point 2. Tried that with bread and 1 bread healed the same amount like 20 breads – Nitro.de Sep 14 '15 at 11:03
  • @Nitro.de Can you confirm that drinking 1 x milk (20 hp/s) and eating 1 x nuts (20 hp/s) will result in 40 hp/s? – Exa Sep 14 '15 at 11:05
  • @exa i can confirm that they stack but i cannot tell if your example will result in 40hp/s – Nitro.de Sep 14 '15 at 11:07
9

Well, Yes and No.

There are 3 different types of "food": Eatable, Drinkable and Potion. These stack with each other. So you can drink Cow Milk and eat Nuts and these effects will stack. If you eat 1 Nut and then 1 raw meat, the remaining healing effect of the nut will vanish. Otherwise it would be way to easy since you could eat 20 Nuts and were unkillable for 5 seconds.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.