I know there are a lot of questions about mob Spawner, and I have read most of them and have tried to fulfill the following condition:

  1. Lit up all caves and possible spawning location within 128 block: I'm in Creative with Superflat world type, so there is no caves, and I've tried to set the world to always daytime, so there are no other possible spawn location other than my dark room, meanwhile if I set the world to cycle day and night, mobs spawn normally on the ground at night, changing the world to survival gives the same result
  2. Mobs won't spawn 24 block from the player, and will freeze if spawned more than 32 block from the player: My dark room floor is located 24 blocks away and the roof is 33 block away from ground
  3. You're on peaceful: No, the world difficulty is set to hardest setting, even zombies can break wooden doors
  4. Use solid block for mobs to be able to spawn: It made entirely of cobblestone and completely dark inside

My dark room mob spawner is the typical 20x20 block (outside frame), with cross shaped flowing water to the center of the room, so the inside volume is 18x18x8 blocks hollowed out. Already tried to separate the 8 block height to two and three floor, but still no result.

I've tried AFK in the collection point on the ground straight below the center of the room for an hour, there's no single mob dropped, and when I fly there to check, there is no single mob either. What could possibly wrong? Please advise.

UPDATE Apparently my mob spawner works if I were far away from the bottom of the spawner, not sure how many block away, probably 24 blocks, my current guess is that you have to be at 24-32 blocks away horizontally AND vertically, not in sphere radius.

PS: I've done quite a bit of reading, but still kinda new to Minecraft, if possible please use noob friendly words or something that I can look up on Wiki. Also pardon my English I'm not native.

  • are you on peaceful mode? – SamsungNote7Plus Sep 23 '15 at 15:08
  • Nope. As stated in my question, difficulty is set on the hardest. And mobs do spawn normally on the ground. – Nur Sep 23 '15 at 15:20

Well, first of all dark room mob spawners aren't very effective unless put to a large scale. I would suggest that you make a 30 by 30 platform which can have another platform 10 blocks above, it has to be nighttime and no other mobs are allowed to spawn around the building, also, you have to have holes in the floor with trapdoors, you can make the trapdoors activate at the hit of a lever. The reason why you want to use trapdoors that are open is because mob AI detect trapdoors as standing blocks whether they are open or closed, also, no water because of update with drowned. Also, its a good idea not to build on slime chunks, can decrease entity spawning. Lastly, one thing for you to check, do /kill @e to reset the entity spawning in area.

I don't know anything fancy but from my experience, mobs like to have something solid to spawn on and also they seems to spawn more often on dry blocks. Also check and see if there are any problems with the system you're using.

  • That exactly what I was asking for, what could possibly wrong from my system. It made of cobblestone so it's full opaque and solid block as stated in question. – Nur Sep 24 '15 at 6:10

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.