19

I recently found one of my supply units (provisioner) at another settlement that means they apparently travel the wastes. Does this mean that they can actually die if they run into some enemies while I'm hanging around? Should I be equipping them with better gear?

  • Provisioners will path between the settlements you assign them to. I've seen them get attacked by raiders before (while they passed by Red Rocket), so if they have no weapons they may get in trouble if you don't save them. But I don't know if this happens when the player is out of sight. – Michael Campbell Nov 13 '15 at 9:48
  • From the title it sounds like you're asking about any settler, but are you only wondering about traveling settlers? As for "at home" settlers, they can definitely die. I had a small (2-person) settlement wiped out by raiders while I was present. – Feral Chimp Nov 15 '15 at 16:58
16

Your settlers at home can die. Note that once a 'settler' has been assigned to a supply route, they will be a 'provisioner' the next time they are loaded.

Provisioners who are away from a settlement can't die. The can get knocked down for a few seconds like other essential NPCs, but they get right back up. Currently, the closest I've observed this is at the Rotten Landfill (east and slightly north of the drive in).

It may be that:

a) Provisioners are just essential always

b) Provisioners who are outside a certain range of a settlement are essential, but can be killed when close to it.

or c) Provisioners who are outside a certain range of their home settlement and/or destination are essential, but can be killed when close to them.

Clearly, more testing is required, but given what I know about how the essential flag works, it's a pretty safe bet that provisioners are just essential all the time, and therefore can't be killed.

  • 1
    For provisioners: Online sources say they can only be killed by friendly fire from you. May want to test this. Also, could you flesh this out a bit more to cover how settlers can die? Will starvation/dehydration do it? – Iszi Dec 1 '15 at 22:47
  • Nobody can die from starvation/dehydration. Not even settlers. The happiness rating only prevents new settlers from coming in, not kill existing ones. You can easily overload a settlement with 40+ guys by buffing CHA, then give them no water and no food. – Nelson Aug 13 '16 at 2:36
2

No, settlers can't be killed by raiders or by anyone apart from you. Apart from the case if you failed to defending quest. They only knee like companions. But you can kill them, and it can happen accidentally during fighting so don't ever use grenades if your settlers are near, they have very low health and also better always to use vats in settlements.

1

Settlers are flagged as protected and can not be killed by NPC's. Period. It doesn't matter if they're in a settlement or travelling as a provisioner. They can technically "die" if you fail to protect a settlement but this isn't because an NPC killed them it's because when you lost the battle, the game despawned one or more of your settlers. The people claiming their settlers were killed by raiders or deathclaw are either flat out lying or accidentally killed their own settlers and didn't notice.

See this video for proof:

0

Ive had a provisioner from Sanctuary die while he was in Oberland Station and we were attacked. Sanctuary then went from 18 -> 17 settlers.

  • 1
    Did the supply route disappear? – Deltharis Nov 24 '15 at 15:55
0

Up untill recently any provisioner (settler that takes care of the supply line) that was attacked and went down got up again a bit later (same as followers). But a while ago I threw a molotov in a group of ferals and it made some cars explode. Just when trowing the molotov I heard someone speaking. It seems a provisioner was just passing by, and yep, he died from the explosion. So they can die, maybe only from really high damage? Did not check if supply line disappeared. I had a savefile, reloaded, and killed ferals with weapon. Provisioner survived and moved on.

  • 2
    Nukapedia says out-of-town Provisioners can only be killed by the PC. So, check your targets! – Iszi Dec 1 '15 at 22:45

protected by Wrigglenite Mar 16 at 23:26

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.