11

While I was browsing my shops in Sanctuary, I heard one of my settlers mention a "bed problem". When I asked my barman if there was any problem around the settlement, he also talked about the "bed problem", and how it "puts everyone on edge".

I have currently 12 settlers and 17 beds in Sanctuary, so it's not like they have to share a bed or something, yet they still don't seem very happy with their beds.

Could it be because I have multiple beds in the same house, or multiple beds in the same room? Do they not like sharing a room with their fellow settlers?

|improve this question
13

What seems to be the problem is that you haven't assigned the beds to anyone, which makes someone wanting a bed to rest look for the closest one and if it is occupied already, makes that person unhappy.

This is based on those 2 threads I found talking about the same problem and that the solution was to assign the beds.

First one :

So I took the time to put it to where I had exactly 20 beds, and then assigned each person a bed that night. It's been a couple days in game, and they haven't complained since.

Second one :

I've had some issues with beds as well. My latest problem was fixed by manually assigning everyone beds in the workshop mode (hit E on settler, then E on bed). Maybe try that.

I'd placed beds in every house in Sanctuary at the start of the game, thinking people might use them eventually so why not. But the settlers picked random beds all over the town, and something about that situation was making them unhappy. So I consolidated the beds into the houses in the center of town, made a town bell to gather my settlers, assigned them all to nearby beds, and put the unused ones into storage.

|improve this answer
  • 5
    I can understand jobs, but having to worry about assigning beds seems like a pointless mechanic. Should have just left it out/made it automatic. – Broots Waymb Nov 18 '15 at 22:10
  • @DangerZone I disagree. If I create a shop with an attached house, I want to be sure that the merchant sleeps in that house, not some random other settler. – sbking Nov 20 '15 at 16:12
  • @sbking, I see your point. Just speaking from my own play style though. I typically don't spend enough time at my settlements to care what people are doing or where they are since I'm exploring. But I can see why you would care. – Broots Waymb Nov 20 '15 at 16:23
  • However, I should add that I'm also not there enough to be annoyed by the bed complaints, so I just don't really care either way. – Broots Waymb Nov 20 '15 at 16:40
3

I don't think the bed actually has to be reachable for the settler. I was delighted when I found that Greygarden build area actually included a chunk of the overpass above - thought it would be a nice, safe place for people to sleep. NPCs never climb the stairs and generally stand around the workshop all night.Beds show they are assigned, and all NPCs are happy.

At Abernathy's, however, people have complained, and I've had to assign beds. I didn't exactly sign up with the Minutemen for parenting some bums.

One thing I found is that NPCs will not step over another sleeping NPC, so don't put beds too close.

|improve this answer
0

I don't think the accepted answer is right, I think the game simply has a bug. It might sometimes be corrected by assigning settlers to specific beds, or storing and re-placing all the beds, but it's still a bug.

I have 18 settlers in Sanctuary and they were complaining even though I had 23 beds (all under roofs, all accessible).

I went through every house and stored all the un-assigned beds in the workshop ... and now I have 19 beds. I've counted it three times, I have 19 assigned beds, but 18 settlers (and one of them is Codsworth, who shouldn't even need a bed, but he does).

So if my settlement can have 19 assigned beds for 18 settlers, something is wrong. It doesn't explain why they were complaining even when there were another four free beds, but hey, it's a bug, who knows what the game's logic is doing.

Edit: I wonder if it's related to the fact that my pip-boy keeps telling me I have a bed shortage, when I still have 20+ beds:

pipboy

|improve this answer
  • That does happen automatically, for example another settler just arrived, and a 20th bed that I'd created became assigned almost right away, so he must have claimed it. So I'm still confused why they keep complaining when they can find a spare bed, and there are enough beds. – boomstick Dec 3 '15 at 18:25
  • Put all beds in the middle of the street where they can easily be found :P – Broots Waymb Dec 3 '15 at 18:29
  • 1
    This doesn't provide an answer but basically explain that it's a bug... which is not an answer. It doesn't provide a way to fix the bug or a way to get rid of the complains. – Jonathan Drapeau Dec 3 '15 at 20:34
  • 2
    @JonathanDrapeau, the answer is "I think it's a bug, there is no reliable fix". Why is that not a valid answer? – boomstick Dec 4 '15 at 10:29
  • 2
    I have that Sanctuary hills bug which fluctuates between what's actually there, and then down to 0 water, 2 beds, etc... The first time, I ran back thinking they'd been destroyed! More interesting is when you link up the pip boy phone app, it actually blinks back and forth between the different values several times per minute. Definitely a bug. – Brendonwbrown Dec 7 '15 at 12:14
0

i fixed this problem by adding flooring and making paths to areas that werent even. i noticed a lot of settlers getting stuck between a wall and a bush, or werent able to climb up a hill or something... making sure there were no obstacles between where the settlers work/congregate and their beds... the complaints stopped

|improve this answer
-1

I saw a comment in an article a few days ago that having more than 4 beds on one floor will make settlers unhappy. Haven't really tested it out myself, mostly because I don't want to put that many beds in one area anyway.

|improve this answer
  • 3
    It would be nice if you could find that article and post the source. That detail would be quite nice to know actually. – Broots Waymb Dec 3 '15 at 19:49

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.