In Chapter 2, two of your fellow inmates are sick, and without medicine they will die (on the same day, no less). One prisoner, Bramble, is pregnant with child. The other doomed prisoner is Mr. Fancy Cakes, who (I'm assured) is totally a unicorn.

The main problem, aside from figuring out the puzzles to get anything done, is that there appears to be only one "miracle cure potion". This sets up the moral dilemma of choosing one over the other.

But is there a way to have my Fancy Cakes, and eat save the pregnant lady too?

  • Short answer no. It is not possible. The achievement for saving everyone actually does not count both of them. It only counts the one you choose.
    – Adam
    Jan 13, 2016 at 19:14

1 Answer 1


Given the multiple Reddit and Steam discussions around this issue all having the same conclusion of not being able to save both Bramble and Mr Fancy Cakes, I would call this answered as "No".

I believe this is intentional to make the player decide whether to save everyone or collect all pages.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .