2

I need to know the term for the kind of projection in games like Cadillacs and Dinosarus (a beat-´em up, shown below). The game uses a kind of pseudo-3D effect with techniques including isometric/axonometric projection, oblique projection, orthographic projection etc

What is the correct term for this behavior? Cavalier, cabinet, isometric, ...?

scenes of cadillacs and dinosaurs

  • Side-scrolling? – peper757 Feb 7 '16 at 18:12
  • yes but, ther is some projection like cavalier or cabinet? – Colomet Feb 7 '16 at 18:14
  • What do you mean by projection? – peper757 Feb 7 '16 at 18:15
  • pseudo-3D techniques include isometric/axonometric projection, oblique projection, orthographic projection – Colomet Feb 7 '16 at 18:22
  • 2
    It's not a form of projection. It's hand drawn art combined using parallax scrolling, as given in camelCase's answer. Individually you could say each piece of art uses, for example, an orthographic or an oblique perspective (it doesn't seem to be consistent), but as a whole the scene isn't using projection. – user86571 Feb 7 '16 at 19:30
10

I believe you are referring to the Parallax Scrolling technique.

Parallax scrolling is a technique in computer graphics and web design, where background images move by the camera slower than foreground images, creating an illusion of depth in a 2D scene and adding to the immersion.

Referring back to the screenshots in OP, this appears to be the technique in play. In order to create the 3D depth illusion a number of images are layered, with the bottom most images on top. Each layer will scroll at a different speed.

To simply the scenario, consider the game screen is split into 3 images:

  • The background
  • The ground
  • The foreground

The foreground is layered on top of the ground, and the ground is layered on top of the background. The background will scroll slower than the ground. The ground will scroll slower than the foreground.

Consider the screenshot in the bottom right.

The grass is in the foreground, and will move across the screen much faster than the dirt pathway as you walk left/right. Also, it will appear over the road and any characters in this plane. The mountains will scroll much slower in comparison to the dirt pathway. Additionally, anything in the plane of the dirt pathway such as characters will appear over the background.

I have used an example of 3 planes, but you will probably find the background has multiple planes itself (e.g. the clouds may move slower than the mountains). The main ground will also have its own plane system so that items lower down the axis will overlap items higher up. To complicate matters slightly, this is different from a character jumping (they will move higher up the screen but remain in the same axis/plane).

As mentioned in the comments, this technique is part of the 2.5D technique.

The Parallax Scrolling technique is used in a large number of games. Streets of Rage and Street Fighter spring to mind. It is also implemented into the SCUMM game engine (although this game engine additionally offers sprite scaling on the y-axis).

  • Yes, but the images of the foreground are created in some kind of projection. are not? – Colomet Feb 7 '16 at 18:44
  • 1
    This has also been referred to as 2.5D, as it is not true 2D like mega man, but not "as 3D" as say, Mario 64 – Dpeif Feb 7 '16 at 18:53
  • @Colomet As mentioned, hand-drawn images can't be easily classified to a specific projection method. For example, floor tiles on 1st, 2nd, 4th images and the car on 6th are clearly isometric, but characters' proprtions can be artistically distorted to fit picture and each other. Some elements, like a wall on the 3rd picture, are drawn in perspective - but they can be only because they are guaranteed to stay on the edge of the screen. – Orc JMR Feb 8 '16 at 13:26
4

I don't think there can be an exact answer to this question because it does not appear that the artist(s) who drew the images adhered to a specific methodology. That said, you can still derive some projection methods used in certain areas.

Oblique Projection looks to be the most primarily used projection method. It is most clear in the top two images where the front of the building is an flat view while the top and sides follow a parallel angle. I measured the angle on the top edge of the building and the cracks of the roof tile to determine it had the expected approximate 30°/150° angles. I can't tell you if it is Cavalier or Cabinet because I don't know the measurements of the building.

See more examples that use this projection method

enter image description here

Perspective Projection is also used in some of these images, particularly the sixth and seventh image where even the foreground is drawn in a way that grows smaller in the distance. This drawing technique's use is more visibly evident from a screenshot from one of the later stages. See how the edges of the top plane of the stairs are not parallel, instead they converge towards a single point in the distance.

enter image description here

With this in mind I feel like you have to take a step back and accept that the artist(s) who drew these images did not have a strictly enforced projection method. They just drew the images so they looked good and provided some semblance of a 3D environment. A combination of that, parallax scrolling, and 3-Dimensional movement (left/right, in/out, jump/fall) gives the player the illusion that they are in a 3D environment.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.