18

For tactical reasons it would be helpful to know, if my opponent sees his cards in the same positions as I see his card backs. Can I rely on what hearthstone shows me, or is it just animation?

Examples:

  1. It's my opponents turn and he is thinking about playing a card, so I can see a card back highlighted. If he plays that card, is it the same he was looking at? If he doesn't play that card, but changes his mind and plays another card instead, and later in the game I see him playing the card which was highlighted before, is it the same card he was looking at some turns before?
  2. The opponent is thinking and after some time he decides to obviously waste a card in order to give him a card draw. The new card is sorted to the right-most position in his hand (from my view). If he plays that card, is it the same, which he just drew? Or if he plays another card, will the card he drew remain in this position of his hand?

Knowing this would give some insight of his tactics and it would be possible to get some ideas what his deck relies on and which cards he is possibly waiting/expecting/hoping for to draw.

Depending on the answers it might be advisable to change oneselves behaviour when thinking about which card to play and not move the mouse above the card.

14

Yes, the cards in your opponents hand are in a fixed order. They are sorted by the time he/she drew them, with the leftmost card being the oldest. If you pay attention you can determine which turn the played card was drawn. There are a couple of tools that can help you with this such as Decktracker, which shows you which turn each card in your opponents hand was drawn.

  • 3
    Note, I would recommend avoiding Decktracker for now, since its in a grey area as far as cheating goes. It's not difficult to tell which card was drawn when anyways. – Waterseas Feb 10 '16 at 17:12
  • 1
    @Waterseas: Can you give any source to why Decktracker is considered as cheating by blizzard? – Zaibis Mar 1 '16 at 10:09
  • 1
    @Waterseas: I don't take this serious since Hearthstone lead designer ben brode explicitly anounced blizzard is fine with tracking software(twitter.com/bdbrode/status/511151446038179840). All else I was able to see is rumor and refference to sources where I have no acces without creating a twitter account. And serious... if HS lead designer anounces on twitter publicly that this software is fine wihtout (even after requests about it) recalling this claim. Then Blizzad has to anounce it more publicly then just in an restricted tweet I can't even access. – Zaibis Mar 1 '16 at 16:24
  • 1
    So if you can't bring up a reasonable source supporting your claim, I see nothing in, but hot air. – Zaibis Mar 1 '16 at 16:26
  • 1
    @Waterseas: thats exactly the post i mentioned. Community manager just comments on something someone posted on twitter what I cant even acess. So you are refering to the same kind of information as I do but mine is public accessable while the one which is claimed to be not accepting it isnt even accessable for anyone. So before saying the sources i present are deveiveing some one into something, show me an public accessable source that disproofs my sources.... – Zaibis Mar 3 '16 at 15:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.