I've been buying food for my 1k+ citizen city but seems not enough, dropping from 100k food to 50k I've planed to buy livestock and kill it rightaway for food, my first impression is: Cattle gives 200 food, (i don't know how much leather) u can sell this for 3 each, and buy vegetables, means u get 600 for doing it. looks like is not worth it, but i don't know with sheeps and chickens, any help?.

My question is different, because im not willing to make fences to farm livestock, I want to kill livestock as soon as i get em. The question is: Is it worth it? considering ships only trading animals are a "waste" in the sense i can't buy food from them, making food gathering slower.


TLDR: Instead of spending your exports on livestock to process at a loss and resell the meat for produce, just buy the the produce with your exports in the 1st place.

If a Trader comes to you with nothing you need, there is nothing wrong with telling him to pack up & move along. The sooner you end your business with a trader the sooner the next one will be along.

In the end, (surplus) Meat, Firewood, simple Coats, and (non-wheat) Ale are great (renewable) exports. Seeds & Livestock are poor imports for any town that already has that particular species.

According to banishedinfo.com: Slaughtering a cow gets you 6 leather & 200 beef, slaughtering a sheep gets you 200 Mutton, and slaughtering a chicken (animal) gets you 6 chicken (food). Making the purchase of Cattle & Chickens for slaughter a "bad trade" & Sheep an investment of labor for no value gained.

  • Cattle @ 800 -> 200 Beef @ 3 + 6 Leather @ 10 = 660 or a loss of 140.
  • Sheep @ 600 -> 200 Mutton @ 3 = 600 or breaking even if you don't count the time invested for the herdsman to slaughter, laborers to store & traders to return to the post.
  • Chickens @ 400 -> 6 chicken @ 3 = 18 or a loss of 382.

Eggs & Wool are byproducts of keeping a number of your chickens & sheep alive.

Why are we doing this?

A) If you want to process imports for profit:

  • Logs -> Firewood
  • Fruit -> Ale
  • Leather or Wool -> Coats

Warm Coats are great for keeping your people working but worth less in trade. Make Hide/Wool Coats for trade.

Tools can be made from imports at a small profit, but as Iron & Coal are not renewable, there may be more value in stockpiling Steel Tools.

B) If you want a source of protein for your people:

If you want to import your protein, buy nuts or fish.

There are 4 sources of home grown protein in the game:

  • Fishing Dock: The Fishing Dock is labor intensive, but has a very small footprint and utilizes otherwise hard to use real-estate.
  • Hunting Cabin: The Hunting Cabin is likewise labor intensive and requires a large land reservation, but in an early town may be your only source of clothing materials.
  • Orchard (growing nuts): Orchards, like Crop Fields, are land and labor efficient, but require a few years before they become productive and are subject to the vagaries of weather.
  • Pasture: Pastures are likewise land and labor efficient, can provide raw materials for your Tailor, but have a considerable startup time. Chickens have a great growth rate, reducing startup time, but produce the least protein and nothing for the Tailor. Cattle in a pasture can be a replacement for your Hunting Lodge. Sheep are king! They supply the most protein for your pasture and wool equal to 3 times the leather produced by the same sized cattle pasture. Prepare to export Wool Coats!
  • 1
    I wouldn't consider that a bug. Sometimes people are just short-sided and will pay more for one thing without considering the alternatives. (That is, unless the mechanics of the game are designed to prevent this.) I wouldn't have any "moral issue" with taking advantage of this, unless it's ridiculously off balance. Just my two cents. – Tim S. Mar 21 '16 at 17:25
  • Well I havn't time on my pc but for the numbers i have IT IS WORTH IT, ull get meat for almost x units of trade in which 2<x<3. I hav'n't thought about it but it is in fact, in the strict mean of exploit, a real exploit but not an overpowered... Someone did mention fruits -> ale, I hadn't thought of that! thx a lot. – José Osorio Mar 22 '16 at 6:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.