8

When you place a brahmin feed trough in a settlement, after a while a brahmin will start feeding from it. However, as the brahmin is eating from it, the trough becomes unmovable. This obviously becomes an issue if I decide that I want to renovate my settlement.

Is there any way to stop the brahmin feeding from it, or just move it away temporarily? I don't think that it's possible to direct a brahmin to move to different places like you can with settlers in construction mode.

If I ever attack a brahmin in my settlement, all of the settlers turn on me, so killing it appears not to be an option.

Do I need to lure something to attack my settlement in order to make it flee? Or do I need to use a tamed creature that I have caught in a cage, and then turn of the Beta Wave Emitter to make it kill the brahmin?

I'm on a console, so console commands aren't available.

  • 2
    From what I can research, you may be able to build another trough and their AI might tell them to move to it? I would have to research it more in my own game before I make a full answer. – Kaizerwolf Jun 21 '16 at 15:22
  • 1
    I would definitely try what Kaizerwolf suggested. Can't guarantee it'll work, but when I wanted to move my cat bowl, making a new one in a different location resulted in the cat going to the new bowl. – pushasha Jun 21 '16 at 17:44
  • have you also tried fast traveling away and back to see if their behavior would reset, which may give you a few precious seconds to remove the trough? (Place a fast travel marker next to it before you try it) – l I Jun 21 '16 at 21:19
  • Testing a few things listed here brought to light one small element of significance. There is no issue in waiting for the Brahmin to finish eating, as the Brahmin only eats for less than a minute. Surely you did try standing around and waiting for at least a couple of minutes? – user106385 Jun 22 '16 at 4:00
5

Playing around with the "feeding Brahmin" myself, I found the simplest way to move the Brahmin away from the feed trough was to simply wait. Failing that, using an extra feed trough can coerce Brahmin to another spot. Alternatively, you can try to kill the Brahmin in stealth. If you are having this problem with the PC version, using the console is always an option.

Wait

This is the first thing you should do. Brahmin only attach to the feed trough while they are eating, and they should only eat for less than a minute. During my testing process, the Brahmin moved from their feeding trough many times.

Using an extra feed trough

Placing an extra feed trough will not immediately call the Brahmin over to the new spot. However, the Brahmin will periodically move back and fourth between available feed troughs.

In fact, technically you do not need to physically place the extra feed trough. In my research, not only will a Brahmin eat from a feed trough that is only being previewed, they will actually favor them.

As you can see in the picture, below, the Brahmin appears to prefer eating from the trough that is currently being previewed, even though the trough can not actually be placed at its current position.

A Brahmin feeding from an invalid preview of a Brahmin feeding trough in Fallout 4

Kill the Brahmin in stealth

As reported, you have the option to simply kill the Brahmin, but that would turn your village against you. Ultimately, what they don't know can't hurt them. Your villagers will not turn hostile if they do not become aware of you attacking the Brahmin.

To kill the Brahmin in stealth, it is better to wait until the twilight hours. Sleep or wait until around 4 a.m., so as to minimalise the amount of villagers roaming around. Find a spot behind some buildings, where you can not be seen, but have clear line to the Brahmin. Enter stealth mode, and ensure that you are actually hidden. While you are hidden, take pot shots at the Brahmin. It might help to move completely into cover, after each shot, to avoid being detected by the Brahmin.

This particular solution may be slow, in comparison to the alternatives. You can not simply "open fire" on the Brahmin, as sustained fire will eventually force you to be detected. But it does work. You will definitely want to save before any attempt, in case you are detected. It might also help to have a companion nearby; Your companion should not interfere while you remain stealth, but will start attacking if you are detected. This makes it easier to ensure that you are still hidden, and will not walk out to a gang of angry villagers.

Using the console

The console is only available if you are playing on PC, but it can be a lifesaver, if all else fails. We will assume you have no problem killing the Brahmin, at this point, as doing so through the console should not turn your villagers aggressive.

  1. Open the console with the console key. By default, this is ~ in the US version of the game, and ' in the UK version. Alternate default keys can be found here.
  2. Left click on the Brahmin. This should change the code currently listed in your console entry, to point to the particular Brahmin you clicked on.
  3. Complete the console line with .kill, so it reads [Brahmin ID].kill.
| improve this answer | |
  • AFAIK, you can also command creature NPCs with a particular perk, though I do not have it, yet. Will do more testing, and update if I find any other alternatives. – user106385 Jun 22 '16 at 4:26
  • 1
    You can get shot at by the Brahmin? – Nelson Jun 22 '16 at 4:30
  • yeah im not sure how that got in haha – user106385 Jun 22 '16 at 4:32
  • 1
    Fwiw if you are using the console you can just move the brahmin instead of killing it. The brahmin eating at a previewed trough is funny though. – l I Jun 22 '16 at 10:08
  • These are all great suggestions. The issue I had with waiting was that if I placed the feed trough the wrong way against a wall, the brahmin would glitch and get stuck inside the wall whilst eating when I arrived at my settlement, and then won't ever finish eating as it can't move. But I will try the other things in order to rectify that. – Mike.C.Ford Jun 22 '16 at 10:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.