2

I have to ask: Is it considered cheating if one plays Pokémon GO while being a passenger in someone’s car? It is incredibly productive but involves minimal physical effort.

How about on a rapid transit system? Like the Subway in New York or the Metrorail in Miami? Would you consider either of those cheating, due to the fast rate at which one encounters Pokémon (and PokéStops) without doing the walking, jogging, and running the game is intended to make you do?

Thank you kindly in advance for your opinions and replies!!

Rafagon

  • I doubt it. If they wanted to prevent you from playing while driving, they could easily based on your gps data. They did it for Ingress. – Carcigenicate Aug 7 '16 at 0:50
  • The game already stops most of the tracking at speeds above 20 kmph / 12 mph. – Elise Aug 7 '16 at 1:18
  • This depends on what is meant by "cheating". One definition of the word is to unfairly gain an advantage. Which could mean that it's cheating to live in a big city. So if the game allows it, it's up to your morales – Aequitas Aug 8 '16 at 2:25
4

No, it's not cheating.

For comparison, you might like to know about the ingress speed limit (What are the exact speed limits for charging and hacking/deploying/xmp firing?). If you're playing ingress in a car moving faster than about 35mph, your app will stop working. This does not happen in Pokemon Go; therefore Niantic is okay with you doing it.

However you probably won't be able to get a cell signal (either GPS or data) while underground in a subway.

If you travel slower than 12ish mph, the game might think you were walking and hatch your eggs. That might be considered cheating if you exploit it deliberately.

It's very effective to sit in one place under some lured pokestops and just collect Pokemon without moving at all. I'm not sure if car-pokemon is any more efficient than that.

  • I've long thought that Ingress's 35-ish MPH Speed Lock is likely 60 KPH (37.28 MPH). And don't some of the official Pokémon Go promo videos show people riding bicycles? – CarlRJ Aug 7 '16 at 4:28
0

While Niantic doesn't specifically state if this is okay or not (that I know of). They have mentioned cheating in their Trainer Guidelines.

They say:

Methods of cheating […] include at a minimum the following: using modified or unofficial software; playing with multiple accounts (one account per player, please); sharing accounts; using tools or techniques to alter or falsify your location; or selling/trading accounts.

Also the game still works when driving at speed so it can be assumed that it is intended that this is okay. Considering that there is a speed lock on hatching eggs. If they intended that you couldn't play while driving (as passenger) then they would have put this same speed lock on catching Pokemon as well.

Also note that recently the scanning speed was reduced from 5 seconds to 10 seconds. Which means that at about 60kmph you will be covering half the area you would've previously. This means you're going to be finding much less Pokemon while travelling fast as the scanner will miss some.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.