I started a game as Pomeranian tribal in the early middle ages bookmark (Charlemagne). Things went really smoothly as a tribal, large armies and I easily defeated the neighbours. The biggest challenge is the succession system, but that can be dealt with by fighting a few wars every time after succession (a hassle but it doesn't destroy your state).

My goal from the start was to eventually transition to a republic and build a trading state that encompasses the Baltic and Scandinavia. This is proving harder than I anticipated. As soon as I transitioned to a republic, my number of troops decreased by a factor of 5-10! I had almost 5k troops I could raise + those of vassals as a tribal, now I have around 500-800.

This wouldn't be such a big problem in itself, as I can hire mercenaries, but since AI looks purely at the levy when deciding which neighbour is weak enough to be attacked, I am getting attacked by virtually everyone around me. I've become a target even for vassals of my neighbours. This makes it difficult to have enough breathing room to raise cash needed for the next invasion, let alone to develop my state and build up the levies. Not to mention prepared invasions where I seem to be everyone's target of choice.

Did I just transition too soon? One of my neighbours (Saxony) had already transitioned earlier to feudal and didn't seem to experience such a large drop in levies, so seems like it's possible to do it without being destroyed.

I worry that if AI wins the next election (which is likely since my treasury is always low due to having to hire lots of mercenaries) then my fledgling state is doomed.

How do I survive this?

  • Since I asked this question I discovered that one thing that works well in early stages is to just keep mercenaries in constant employ. It lowers your income significantly, but it's much more expensive to keep fighting constant wars. – SMeznaric Oct 9 '16 at 16:02
  • The transition from tribal to anything is difficult - feudal lords-to-be also suffer a huge drop in available forces for a decade or so, making them vulnerable to both neighbors and internal squabbles from vassals that didn't upgrade. There are a couple of ways to mitigate this, my favorites are (in order easy -> complex): 1) Alliance with someone big 2) Gold & mercs 3) Do a partial upgrade only (This one can be achieved by having pagan counties or taking a couple of neighbor counties immediately after the upgrade and not upgrading them) – Ordous Nov 2 '16 at 19:54
  • Interesting ideas, you should put that in an answer. – SMeznaric Nov 2 '16 at 20:30
  • I don't have Charlemange or The Republic and I've only played pagan tribals in eastern europe and never played as a patrician - so my experience is limited with regards to this particular question! But I've not found any questions about the upgrade on this site actually, so might be worth sharing at least something. I'll look around again in the evening, if nothing comes up I'll try to give some advice. – Ordous Nov 3 '16 at 14:19

Upgrading from tribal settlements is always tricky, whether you are aiming for a republic or feudalism! I don't have much experience with republics at all, so I'll give general advice. These are loosely ordered from easy to complex/historical to gaming the system. (Note: the last 2 bullet points no longer work with the latest patches as you cannot build multiple tribal holdings in one county and get crippling penalties for wrong holding type. I'll leave them in for historical accuracy)

  • Make allies. Preferably 2 that don't have any conflicts with each other. Allies will help you against external enemies, as well as factions. Notes: they won't come help if they have a war of their own, they won't always come help if the war is from you trying to revoke a title and you have to renegotiate the alliance if a character dies (best marry off your sister to a realm with Gavelkind or Primogeniture and a ready heir)

  • Gold. If you have enough gold, you can just use mercs whenever needed. You will likely need them anyway, as the first years are crippling, but it's good to have some extra just in case.

  • Get some pre-upgraded counties OR make sure your core tribes are fully built out. The problem with the upgrade is that you lose the levy bonus from empty slots, that will be later compensated by buildings. If you fully upgrade your tribes first (or capture some upgraded castles or cities and build those out), you won't suffer as much of a hit.

  • Shed your realm. Tribalism is not meant to be stable in the game (nor was it historically so). If you have blood relatives who don't have claims to lands take up surrounding counties and get independence, they are unlikely to try and assault you (they only band together if you are their liege), nor do you have lots of vassals threatening you. This way you get an upgraded core of several counties + a few loyal vassals (make sure they are content and honest!!!) and later on you can either reconquer, marry or vassalize your former subjects (They aren't too fussy about it, since they share your religion, culture and dynasty. Also they are probably very grateful for the 10+ years of independence and likely are de-jure vassals as well.)

  • Swear fealty to a feudal lord. This allows you to upgrade to feudalism without the worries of the above (does not allow upgrading to a republic like this, even if you join a republic). This is in a last section, since this is almost always paired with revoking as many counties as possible, dropping your primary title, swearing fealty, upgrading, then taking your new lieges titles (since you likely have more land than him). Not something a real ruler would allow, but AI's are more than happy to get an extremely powerful vassal.

  • Make a partial upgrade. When you upgrade, all your holdings will upgrade. Some of your vassals will, some won't. Infidels will not have the option at all. Hence, you lower your county count, upgrade, up your crown authority and revoke tribes back to yourself. If your ruler is weak and about to die, you can even try to up the authority to medium, which gives free revocation from infidels. Or, if you have a couple of brothers without sons, you can give them some badly upgraded tribes (so they don't try and convert), then kill them off and inherit the tribes. Or, if there are several small independent tribal counties around you that you have claims to (or de-jure rights to), take them after the upgrade and don't upgrade them. Either way, the goal here is to convert only some tribes, while keeping others intact, for a smoother transition.

This is applicable for raiding tribals or if you have some other magic way to get tens of thousands of prestige, and a capital (original or not) with several free holding slots.

  • Build tribal settlements in your capital county. The idea here is to upgrade them all and net the capital county and marshal bonus for the castles. In your typical game, adding a second tribal settlement is going to reduce your total levy in that county (this is because the empty holding bonus on a fully-upgraded tribe is larger than the levy provided by a fresh tribe), fully upgrading it (6k-10k prestige + around 500 gold) is going to increase it a bit, but not as much as a tribal settlement in a different county with empty slots (as you would have more empty slot bonuses than capital county bonus). So you would usually want to expand the number of counties you have to make use of the empty slot bonus rather than capital county & marshal bonuses. The downside is that this bonus that you have been maxing out disappears when upgrading to feudalism. Hence - don't max it out. Get it early to make raiding and warfare viable, and then slowly condense your realm back to your capital. This will make the levy hit from upgrading miniscule - you'll go from ~2k levy from each tribe to ~1-1.5k from each castle (assuming a good marshal training troops - he affects all your castles in the county!). You'll then be able to build Stables in each of those castles pushing your army size back to the original, except now it's heavy infantry + cavalry, rather than light infantry. As a sweet bonus - if you had 8 tribes before upgrading, and they are all now castles with Training Grounds II (you get those via upgrade even if you don't posses the tech for it), and you have Military Organization II, then you'll get 1.4k+ retinue points right there, allowing you to start building up a private standing army right after the upgrade. The best places for such a buildout will have both a good number of slots, rich raiding targets and same faith neighbors to conquer and protect from holy wars. These are the Swedish capital (don't remember the duchy name, essentially where Stockholm is now), Jylland (Danish capital, 2 6-slot counties), Lithuania (5 slot county + 2 4-slot ones), Kiev (7!!! slot county + 5 slot one), Moravia (Praha is 6 slot IIRC + several OKish nearby). If playing in the British Isles with an early start, conquering Essex is also a good way to go, if the opportunity arises.

Yeah, the solution to that is to raise all levies before the conversion, they stay with their strong numbers while your new holdings upgrade, and the AI will look at your 3k raised army, not your 500 "posible" army. The only bad thing about that are: 1- you get less money because the upkeep. 2- You cant declare offensive wars (not that you want to) 3- If the AI STILL declare war on you and they get beaten, its game over.

As a side note, if you are an offensive pagan (meaning Tengri or norse) you can raise your vassal levies for extra punch, since those religions dont have the "raised vassal levy for too long" malus. For these offensive pagans, you can use those raised troops for raiding for money while at it.

With that and the retinues, you should have an easier time. Heck, if you are playing with the horse lords, you can add the event troops you got when you settled, if they survived your tribal age. Boom, like 9k levies, should be enough to hold.

  • Thanks for the interesting answer. So I ended up solving the problem by buying some mercenaries and just keeping them in employ until my levies built up, but this solution might turn out to be cheaper. The bummer is that the AI doesn't take your cashflow + wealth into account when deciding whether to invade so I really needed to keep some mercs around to show the AI that they shouldn't mess with you. – SMeznaric Jul 26 '17 at 13:38

Merchant republics don't have a lot of their own levies anyway; their military might comes from setting up a vast income to splurge on mercenaries. So you're hit with a double whammy; not just temporarily low on troops by losing tribal bonuses and not having lots of infrastructure built up yet, but also working with merchant republic's low troops per initial holding.

One thing you can do that's not covered by Ordous answer is avoid having neighbours that can just freely declare conquest wars on you. If there are large realms nearby of a different religion (especially entirely different religious group), then any sign of weakness will tend to invite holy wars. If you're big enough to scare them now but won't be immediately after converting, be proactive and conquer yourself some buffer duchies/kingdoms.

You can either keep them as "acceptable losses" to give away in the inevitable wars, or you can just grant them independence and babysit them through alliances until they're stable (I like to play tribal gavelkind by conquering enough land to let all of my children inherit independent realms anyway, since I long ago got over the tedium of managing super-empires). That way when you're converted and vulnerable your neighbours will be of your religion and culture (and preferably dynastic allies too, though you'll want them without strong claims; either put your cousins in charge rather than your brothers, or wait a generation); even if the heathens take advantage of your bloc's loss of power, their first conquests won't be you, and you'll have time to invest and grow back into a major regional power.

Swearing fealty to a bigger nearby power has a similar effect; your liege will protect you from conquering nomads or heathens, and your fellow vassals will generally have to spend time playing the marriage game or fabricating claims in order to attack you. That was how I did my recent playthrough as nomad Magyar going merchant republic, but my plan all along was to join the Byzantine empire and eventually subvert it to create a new Roman Republic. The most critical time was actually the tribal period between nomad and merchant; I had to be independent in order to create a merchant republic, but I was surrounded by terrifying nomad hordes of my unconverted kinsmen (and tribal levies are particularly useless against nomad hordes, due to troop composition). As soon as I was a republic I swore fealty to the emperor.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.