-1

I, like many, LOVED Final Fantasy VII on it's release and I've played through it a couple times. It wasn't until today when I played through the original demo disc (I just received my copy of Tobal No. 1) that I realized that the "flower girl" is on the top level of Midgar!

I guess I never noticed this because it's Midgar at night and it still has that same dark and dingy feel as the lower level. Anyway, later on when Aeris finds Cloud in the church we learn that the Turks had been pursuing her for practically her entire life. This matters because we learn from Jess that if you are going to the top level of Midgar, the train scans the ID badges of all individuals at certain check-points. If someone is without an ID badge, or if they are on a hazardous persons list, the sirens will go off and Midgar police will apprehend the criminal.

Aeris is not a criminal but she couldn't have an ID badge because, if she did, she could easily be identified as the "ancient" that she is? Reno and the other Turks could then easily apprehend her.

Of course, Barret, Cloud and the rest of Avalanche crew had fake IDs which worked well at least twice-- on the trip up to the top level of Midgar to blow up the first reactor, and on the trip home. However, I seem to recall that these IDs were either expensive or hard to come by, so I doubt Aeris could have had a fake ID.

So... How did she get to the top level of Midgar?

  • 1
    I don't really follow why Aeris's ID badge, if she were to have one, would label her as an ancient. We don't really know what identifying information are on Midgar ID badges, and Aeris was being hidden anyway, so it's highly unlikely she'd volunteer that information when she heads to her local Midgar administration office to apply for her ID. – Ellesedil Nov 18 '16 at 21:42
  • Aeris is a bit of a "hidden" person. Aeris adopted mother received her from birth mother and was instructed to keep her hidden. She wouldn't have an ID badge or it could be assumed that government "officials" would have started asking questions regarding her origin once her adoptive mother attempted to get her an ID. Now, if she did manage to get one, all it would take is for the Turks to try and scan her ID badge. Apparently, they've had multiple, close calls at catching her as confessed by Aeris in the church. The Turks would have certainly tried something like this if that were plausible. – RLH Nov 18 '16 at 21:49
  • Without some evidence, I think you might be taking some liberties on what would have happened. In order for her ID to label her as an ancient, she'd need to either label herself as one (seems unlikely) or the Midgar government would need to connect all of the dots between who she is, what she is, and her ID somehow. Since we don't really know how far along the Turks are in their investigation at the time of the scene you mention, or how they got to a point where they could confront Aeris at the church, we can't know for sure that she doesn't possess a valid ID badge. – Ellesedil Nov 18 '16 at 22:07
  • If you really follow FFVII Universe, Turks is just watching Aerith as a last tribute for Zack (because Cissnei and Tseng). They only try "capture" her when President Shinra issuing the order (they are not tried really hard). Shinra is not suspicious of them because he think as an Ancient , Aerith have some kind of power that make her able to defeat Turks he sent. So it's easy for Turks agent to looks another way when they see her. But everything changed when Rufus started taking over Promised Land Project from his old man. – Rusted_Silver Nov 19 '16 at 7:49
2

If we accept

  • The only way between the top and bottom levels of Midgar is via train (assuming that staircases would be too heavily guarded for even Avalanche to try to take)
  • Aeris would have to commute between lower / upper levels for work on this train
  • The only way to ride the train is with a valid id card
  • Aeris hasn't been arrested

Then ipso facto Aeris must have a "valid" ID card.

Why is this so hard to believe? There is no reason to suspect that she must have a valid ID card in her name or that the Turks even know what ID card she is using, so short of them sorting through every single commuter systematically there is no way to pin her down.

So, how did she get this ID card? Apart from the short dialog in the train, we know nothing about them. We do know they can be forged, and that Avalanche would rather forge enough cards for their entire crew than just steal some from drunk/asleep people on a train. Maybe this is because in their self-righteous nature they don't want other people to get in trouble for not having an ID card, or maybe ID cards aren't that hard to forge. Does this mean that Aeris could get a forged ID card? Probably. She is familiar enough with the characters in the slums (for example, that guy who are sick), and she is one tough cookie (I mean, she hangs out in a slum infested with HellHouses), so she is probably savvy enough to get her hands on a card. Hell, she's worldly enough not to bat an eye when it comes time to help get Cloud ready for Don Corneo.

But this doesn't mean she has a forged ID card. Let's look at this other scenario (spoilers ahoy! I'm going to try to not use anything other than FFVII as canon): Aeris is 7 when her mother breaks out of Shinra HQ with her, and knowing her death is near, passes her off to a woman who is waiting for her husband to get back from the Wutai War. Now, Shinra knows the Ancients under their control have escaped, and they would definitely be looking for them. But, Aeris and her mother were able to get to Sector 7 without being detected, which means that the ID card system probably didn't exist yet. So, some time in the next 15 years, Aeris (and maybe her adopted mother) probably went through the regular legal mumbo jumbo of getting an ID card. It doesn't really matter that she might not be able to prove her birthplace or lineage, as during Aeris's age of 7 and 16, the Wutai War was going on and creating refugees; she is also from the slums, so there is no reason that they would even bother with having some kind of accurate census to base that kind of information off of. So, one day, a bright-eyed kid walks into the equivalent of a DMV, lines up with a bunch of other slum trash and wants to get an ID card so she can ride the train up to the land of opportunity. The bored clerk (even if there was a clerk. It could just have been a machine) looks at her and says "Do you have the registration fee?", takes her cash, maybe a bribe, takes a photo and registers her under the name of Useless McGetsStabbedInTheBack.

  • Fantastic name for her – mmatthews Nov 21 '16 at 20:19
1

Turks is watching Aerith as a last tribute for Zack (because Cissnei and Tseng). They only try "capture" her when President Shinra issuing the order (they are not tried really hard). Shinra is not suspicious of them because he think as an Ancient , Aerith have some kind of power that make her able to defeat Turks he sent. So it's easy for Turks agent to looks another way when they see her. And only a few people know about her identity as Ancient, so for other Shinra Employee she is just another flower seller. But everything changed when Rufus started taking over Promised Land Project from his old man. or because Aerith got involved with terrorist group (Avalanche)

For ID card,they never removed her privilage for when she is working for Shinra with Zack.She often visiting Shinra with Zack before Promised Land planned.

In Layman terms, Aerith can go to Upper Plate because Tseng as the leader of Turks have a close relationship with Zack (Aerith's Boyfriend),Cissnei (Zack's Friend) and Aerith (His Friend/love interest(?)) and have final say when to capture Aerith. Only after Aerith got involved with Avalanche (He have a really bad experience with them in Before Crisis) he started to following Shinra order to capture her.

-2

It's true that the train scans badges at the various checkpoints. But Aeris didn't necessarily use the train to move around. It's very likely she took some other means of travel to get to lower Midgar, such as floating down(she is a healer/white mage after all) as she would know about the train issues. It's also possible she takes the train, but the distance is so short, that it's between checkpoints.

  • 6
    There are a couple of problems with this. First, Aeris can't fly. I mean, we see no proof of it. Second, I recall the train was the only way up or down to the top levels, except by certain maintenance stairs in certain sectors which, you guess it, also had check points. Regarding the check points, the train circles around they center support column for the disc above. The check points are on the tracks in this area so if you are going up or coming down, you will have to go through a check point. No way around it. – RLH Nov 18 '16 at 21:14
  • Well, i did say Float :D. Float is a Final Fantasy spell, maybe she hovered her way back down. – King of NES Nov 18 '16 at 21:17
  • 2
    I don't think this is acceptable but since it can be fun to speculate/role-play... This wouldn't be possible because Midgar NO DOUBT has special, aerial security. All "unknown" flying objects (or people) would be shot down before entering the city. We know this to be true because if Junon has taught us anything, it's that Shinra likes protecting it's towns from flying creatures with really REALLY big guns! – RLH Nov 18 '16 at 21:19
  • 1
    except when it's Highwind, , , , – Rusted_Silver Nov 19 '16 at 9:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.