I'm trying to summon a dynamic block that looks like a banner. This:

/summon falling_block ~ ~ ~ {Block:standing_banner,Time:1,NoGravity:1}

summons a falling block alright, but it's invisible. I can tell it's there by the shadow, but it doesn't drop an item when it despawns (which is weird, considering that I haven't touched the DropItem tag.) Using Block:wall_banner does exactly the same thing, and using an invalid block id fails to summon anything. If I omit the NoGravity tag, the entity is still invisible until it hits the ground and becomes a block.

This command:

/summon falling_block ~ ~ ~ {Block:hopper,Time:1,NoGravity:1}

summons a perfectly visible falling block that looks like a hopper and drops as an item when it despawns. They're both data holder blocks, so I have to think it's something specific to banners that makes this happen. Anyone have any thoughts as to what that might be, or how to get around it?

  • Which Minecraft version are you playing in? The entity IDs changed recently (I think 1.11), so it's important to know.
    – user176681
    Jan 17 '17 at 5:07
  • Yeah, I'm using 1.11. The pre-1.11 id was FallingSand, I think.
    – TenNineAce
    Jan 17 '17 at 5:09
  • I just tested this, with the same results. I also found that chests behaved exactly the same as banners. Aren't chests this weird kind of block called a "Tile entity" or something? I'm not exactly sure. It's probably the same problem.
    – user176681
    Jan 17 '17 at 5:14
  • They are, but so are all containers, including hoppers. Notably, though, both banners and chests don't take up a full block. brb trying some other blocks with smaller hitboxes... nope, brewing stands work just fine, so that's not it.
    – TenNineAce
    Jan 17 '17 at 5:18

This is not possible, see MC-64634. Via Grum's comment, explaining that this will not work for various blocks:

Using it for anything other than the original block might make it not work.

It doesn't work for the ones without blockmodels.

Since banners do not have a block model, it cannot be rendered with the falling_block entity. Hoppers, on the other hand, do have a block model, and so will render properly.

  • 1
    Well done. Deleted my answer because mine said the same thing and yours is more concise. +1.
    – user176681
    Jan 17 '17 at 5:33
  • block models, that was the difference. Huh, do chests not have a block model either? Live and learn. Thanks for the answer, shame there's no way around it.
    – TenNineAce
    Jan 17 '17 at 6:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.