In particular, are there any restrictions between Pokémon Diamond/Pokémon Pearl and Pokémon SoulSilver/Pokémon HeartGold?


There are no trade restrictions between gen 4 games. I have traded from HG and SS to Platinum.

For D/P/P

  • You must have received the Pokedex from Professor Rowan at Sandgem Town


  • You must have received a Pokedex from Professor Oak at Mr. Pokemon's house (North of Cherrygrove City)

You would need 2 DS consoles and then just head to the Union Room, found in the Pokemon Centre, on both games and trade from there. You will need 2 Pokemon in your party to be able to trade.

Issues arise when trading between generations (gen 3 to gen 4, for example) as Pokemon, their Moves and their Held Items, may not exist in the past or future.

  • AFAIK; the only restrictions for transferring are no HM moves (Pal Park [G3 -> G4], Transfer Lab [G4 -> G5]) and no held items (Transfer Lab [G4 -> G5]). After Gen 1/2's time capsule, transferring has been one-way - and some Pokemon can only learn some moves in previous generation games, and must be transferred from that game to have the move in a newer game. (see Delibird's Serebii page, the "Transfer Only Moves" section near the bottom.) – Trent Hawkins May 7 '17 at 9:43
  • I'm aware of the one way transferring. I added the Pokemon restriction in the last paragraph because (if I remember correctly) you can still trade from Gen 2 back to Gen 1 if the Pokemon, Type and Moves existed in Gen 1. – Supergoat21 May 7 '17 at 9:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.