For quite a long time I've had an extremely vexing problem on Lego Marvel Super Heroes for Xbox 360. When playing split screen co-op, one controller has the thumbsticks configured right handed, and the other has them reversed (left handed). I thought maybe I'd just accidentally switch them in the settings somewhere, but I couldn't find any option to change them. I also looked into my console settings, but on 360 I don't seem to have the option to change. Is there any way to change this setting to make both controllers right handed?
I had thought there might just be something weird with this one game on XBox 360, so I later moved on to playing Lego Marvel Avengers on XBox One and never had the same issue. I recently attempted to play Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga on my XBox One (note: a totally different console) - and I experienced the same issue. I do not experience this issue with any other games on my XBox 360 or XBox One. I've combed the internet and can't find any reference to anyone having a similar issue.