I'm looking to reward the players of levels I make in Super Mario Maker 2 for finding secret areas, getting past difficult sections, etc.

In the original Super Mario Brothers series (Super Mario Brothers 3, Super Mario World, etc) the subjectively "best" reward was a 1-Up Mushroom, granting an extra life. Coins might be a second best as they granted points, and 100 coins would be a 1-Up.

In Super Mario Maker 2, from what I can tell, 1-Up Mushrooms have no value: When I play courses locally through the "Play" option I haven't seen any counter for lives, and so getting an extra life seems to have no value (they're effectively infinite)

Do 1-Up mushrooms have any value in in Super Mario Maker 2? If not, what are good "rewards" to place in secret / difficult to find areas? What do players value and try to find?

  • ...I understand this question borders on subjective and have tried to make it fit the Stack Exchange style as best as I can! – Josh Jul 26 '19 at 3:46
  • I don't know if this is changed from Mario Maker 1 but 1-ups in that game only affect you if you're doing a 10x Life Challenge or something like that and only reward you the extra life if you beat the level. – Robbie Jul 26 '19 at 4:19

It depends.

If you have a somewhat challenging level it might end up in endless mode. There 1-Ups are at least a little bit of value, since you can collect 3 per level to add to your total live counter. Especially for every mode past easy it is helpful to have your live counter stocked up for stages that require a few more tries.

In normal mode, where you can choose levels as you wish 1-ups are really not worth your time, as long as you did not set the win condition to collecting enough.

It may be better to reward your players with a mushroom or a fire flower here, since those are more versatile usable if you value normal play over endless modes.

But I personally would refrain from giving the player a movement improving item (like propeller mushroom, cape or tanookie leaf), since that is usually a way to break a level and get through it really fast without really admiring it.

Another way to reward a player for finding a secret area might be, that you set a win condition. If the player has to get a set amount of a special Item and he finds one or two of them in your secret area they don't have to look for them later on. That does work pretty good with 1-Up Mushrooms.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    In general, it's common courtesy to always give the player access to three one-up mushrooms (or the equivalent in coins - i.e. 100 coins per one-up) in every level, for the benefit of those playing in Endless Mode. (As three one-ups is the cap for extra lives you can earn in that mode). Technically the most you can carry over in Endless Mode is 3 one-ups and 99 additional coins. – Showsni Jul 26 '19 at 8:46

You still can put an 1UP as a reward...

Although it's pointless if a player get into your course from random search, but 1UP will be a useful reward while your course been played in endless challenge mode.

Your question reminded me of putting some 1UP and some 10/30/50-coin in my course.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.