Summoning a husk with an nbt of HandItems:[{id:"minecraft:stick"},{}] spawns a husk holding a stick in its mainhand but using it on an execute command to check the entity also works on a husk holding a stick in its offhand. The command that I used:

/execute as @e[type=husk,nbt={HandItems:[{id:"minecraft:stick"},{}]}] run say I have a stick in my mainhand!


/execute as @e[type=husk,nbt={HandItems:[{},{id:"minecraft:stick"}]}] run say I have a stick in my mainhand!

also works.

I want to check if a husk is holding a stick in its mainhand but I can't figure out the exact command to do what I want.


Firstly, you forgot the stack size:

/summon husk ~ ~ ~ {HandItems:[{id:"stick",Count:1},{}]}

Secondly, there are two very similar syntaxes, which causes this unintuitive behaviour: When summoning an entity, [{},{}] creates a list with two entries. But when checking for NBT, the same syntax checks for the presence of the two entries in the list. And both {}, meaning any entry, and {id:"minecraft:stick"}, meaning an entry with key id and value "minecraft:stick" are matched, so the command runs.

How to actually check for the correct index: Normally you could just use /execute if data, but due to an oversight in the NBT path syntax, a path like HandItems[1]{id:"minecraft:stick"} does not work. What you need to do instead is copying the NBT somewhere else and then checking there.

The proper way to do this is to create a datapack and run a function as the husk, that way you can check the NBT without interfering with anything in the world by using storage:

data modify storage temp Mainhand set from entity @s HandItems[0]
execute if data storage temp Mainhand{id:"minecraft:stick"} run say I have a stick in my mainhand!
data remove storage temp Mainhand

The hacky way to do this does not require a datapack, but it modifies the held item. The tag tag of items can contain any arbitrary NBT, so you can copy the entire item NBT into a sub-tag of the item NBT. Yes, that's stupid, but it doesn't require a datapack. If you just want something copy-paste ready, this is for you:

/execute as @e[type=husk] run data modify entity @s HandItems[0].tag.temp set from entity @s HandItems[0]
/execute as @e[type=husk,nbt={HandItems:[{tag:{temp:{id:"minecraft:stick"}}}]}] run say I have a stick in my mainhand!
/execute as @e[type=husk] run data remove entity @s HandItems[0].tag.temp

Thanks to vdvman1 and PeerHeer in the Minecraft commands Discord group for their help with this answer!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.