Does anyone have a consistent way of getting Mireille's/Gatekeeper's missions in Chapter 9? (Ie. "The Price of Thievery" and "Shear's Counterattack")? Every guide I've read online contradicts another one.

I followed the steps in PowerPyx's guide on my first playthrough:

  • Sam Dialogue (Chocobo Cowboy): When describing Tifa to him pick “She’s great at handling the books”.
  • In Wall Market, don’t talk to the guy in front of the hotel and don’t talk to the hotel receptionist.
  • In Wall Market, Ignore the Johnny Discovery Event (where he runs away) and head straight for the main objective.
  • When Sam does the coin flip, pick “Heads”.
  • Pick the most expensive massage “Luxury Course – 3000 Gil”
  • When Aerith asks how you like her outfit “Looks comfortable”.

PowerPyx is usually pretty reliable, but I follow these instructions and I did NOT get the alternative missions. On my next playthrough I just picked the following options:

  • She's in great shape
  • Didn't talk to the hotel people
  • Ignored Johnny
  • Heads
  • Luxury
  • Alright

And I still didn't get the alternative missions. I'm about to start my third and I don't know what to select... :(

IGN's guide says:

  • Do not participate in Sam's coin toss
  • Choose the Expensive Massage Course

Gamerant's guide says:

  • Choose "No deal" during Sam's coin toss.
  • Receive the "Luxury" from Madam M.
  • Say "It matter what I think?" or "Looks comfortable" when asked about Aerith's dress.
  • Complete the Vagabond Johnny discovery side quest.

Another guide says:

  • Hotel guy: How much?
  • Sam: Tails
  • Massage: Luxury
  • Outfit: It matter what I think?

Yet another says:

  • Don't talk to the hotel guy
  • Sam: Heads
  • Massage: Luxury
  • Outfit: Comfortable

Surely someone knows the 100% definitive way to unlock them properly? All evidence seems to suggest it's completely random? Thanks.


It seems Game8.co's guide has the answer. Phew! This worked for me:

enter image description here

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.