I was watching this video, which briefly covers the first Halo (Halo Combat Evolved).

At 14:00 there is a confrontation before the monitor becomes an enemy in the game.

Who did the Monitor I assume incorrectly think that the Master Chief was, perhaps a forerunner? In the scene the Monitor was fairly confused, stating "But you already knew that... I mean, how couldn't you?" and "Last time you asked me, if it were my choice, would I do it?".

1 Answer 1


Guilty Spark refers to The Chief as "Reclaimer". This is an ambiguous title, not specific to any particular person.

A Reclaimer is an individual who, whether by chance or by precedent, has been placed in charge of activating a Halo super-weapon. [...] The exact qualifications of a Reclaimer are not entirely clear, but only a human or Forerunner can be a Reclaimer. Reclaimer has often been used by Forerunner AI and Huragok as a general term for humanity, although not all humans appear to qualify.


In the original game, the context is ambiguous, making this a little vague as to what or who he believes he is talking to. However, in the extended canon, it is made a bit clearer:

The arrival of the Covenant on the ring instigated Installation 04's genocide and the final Flood outbreak. Immediately putting long dormant contingency measures into action, Guilty Spark began to search for a Reclaimer and discovered UNSC Staff Sergeant Marvin Mobuto. Using Halo's teleportation system, Guilty Spark brought Mobuto to the Library in an effort to retrieve the Index. Ultimately, although he fought hard, and endured the Flood almost to the Index, the ill-equipped Marine failed and was killed, forcing the Monitor to seek out another Reclaimer. John-117 discovered the body of Mobuto (which was mangled beyond usage by the Flood) during his own journey through The Library, though it can't be seen in-game, and marveled at the Staff Sergeant's ability to get as far as he had with less optimal equipment.


So what we can take from this is that 343: Guilty Spark does not see the individuals, or even distinguish between two individuals, particularly in the role of the "Reclaimer".

"Ah" 343 Guilty Spark said, peering down over the Spartan's shoulder. "The other Reclaimer. His combat skin proved less suitable than yours."
The soldier looked up over his shoulder. "What do you mean?"
"Is this a test, Reclaimer?" The Monitor seemed genuinely puzzled.

Halo: The Flood by William Dietz p. 244

  • If that is true, surely Guilty Spark would have known the last Reclaimer died, so why would he think John 117 was the same person...? Guilty Spark would not have re-started his search for a new person if he thought the original person was still alive...
    – questioner
    Apr 17, 2021 at 19:22
  • @questioner my first sentence answers that question
    – Ben
    Aug 11, 2021 at 5:21

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .