I'm doing the mission where you're sent to Palaven's moon to rescue the Turian primarch, you need to repair a communications tower. I have the option to either send James or Liara.

Does the progress or outcome of the mission change at all depending on who I choose? Am I at risk of losing anyone? I know this seems kind of weird to ask so early in the game, but after having so recently finished ME2 and having to choose people for the Suicide Mission (and this is war, y'know), I'm a little paranoid.

3 Answers 3


It makes no difference. It just comes down to who you want by your side while you fight off the wave of husks, an event that lasts only a minute or two. After that, your party member will rejoin you.

If you could lose a party member this way, I would have happily used it to kill off James Vega.

  • Haha, wow, you really hate him, don't you?
    – FAE
    Mar 9, 2012 at 17:51
  • My Shepard's already got all the unchecked testosterone the Normandy can handle!
    – Sterno
    Mar 9, 2012 at 17:52
  • @FallenAngelEyes: You guys just gave me a great idea for something. It'll have to wait until tonight or tomorrow though.
    – MBraedley
    Mar 9, 2012 at 18:28

Surprisingly, yes. The more technical minded Liara will complete the objective faster then the meathead James. This will result in one extra round of husks because James is far slower then Liara about fixing things. He'll succeed of course but you and Liara will face extra husks for your troubles. But no, you won't lose anybody.

This happens later on in other missions but if you're tech heavy (such as having both Tali and EDI in the squad) it doesn't matter.


Unlike in Mass Effect 1 or 2, in Mass Effect 3, all characters are equally competent at hacking, decrypting, and repairing anything you might find in the world.

In Mass Effect 3, the game likes to force you to temporarily give up one of your squadmates to make a certain "Defend" segment harder. Ultimately, there is no effect, as your squadmates "serendipitously" always finish as soon as you kill the last enemy.

Funny how that works.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .