18

It is all written in the title but an image could help.

How can conquer or destroy this city?

A city on an island with no surrounding land tiles

1 Answer 1

27

You CAN attack out of boats. There are just some problems with this:

  • CORRECTED: The defenders get +50% strength for your units making an Amphibious Landing. (similar to attacking across a river, except that defender bonus is only 25%) This can be removed by taking the Amphibious unit upgrade. This upgrade is sadly level 3: Combat I > Combat II > Amphibious.

    Some units start with this upgrade: Berserkers, the Viking special unit, and Marines (including Navy Seals, the American special unit).

  • If I recall correctly, you can not use land units to bombard from ships. You can however: use ships that can bombard, or bombard with aircraft. (OR nuclear weapons late in the game, if it comes to that)

  • You can try espionage to weaken the defenses first.

  • You can always take over the city with culture, although that doesn't look likely in this case.

You can improve your chances with smart unit upgrades and bombarding, but you're ultimately going to have to attack out of your boats, quite possibly with a lot of units.

I do wonder: Why do you NEED to take the city? If that city (and others like it) are all that's left of a Civ, why not accept capitulation?

EDIT: Pics or It Didn't Happen

Please forgive the size of these pictures. I was not sure how to edit them down without making the combat text unreadable.

Test Setup: I used galleys and gave myself no techs to prove it could happen early in the game. Didn't bother to fortify the defender since that's not important to what I'm testing, but the difference certainly makes this look easy! Two galleys vs a single tile island city

Here you can see the dreaded +50%. I wanted to compare the odds of taking Amphibious or an upgrade against a unit type, thus here you see Cover. (+25% VS Archery units) Combat odds for Macemen with Cover attacking

Here you can see a Maceman with Amphibious, and the dreaded +50% is gone. I was concerned that taking Amphibious was not as good as other upgrades, (when I thought the penalty was only -25%) but it is CLEARLY better, if you can get your unit to level 3. Combat odds for Macemen with Amphibious attacking

The payoff: City taken with Amphibious attack

Notes:

  • Please forgive the macemen glowing. I gave them experience AND the upgrades by accident with the map editor, but checked the odds with the upgrades differing by just Cover vs Amphibious.
  • Test was done in Beyond the Sword, although I REALLY think this works the same in vanilla and Warlords.
  • I initially remembered the penalty was only 25%, which has now been corrected!
  • Because I was wrong about the penalty for attacking out of ships, I checked attacking across a river. It is 25% as I thought, I've just corrected the wording to match the wording/effect in the game (25% penalty to you vs 25% bonus for defender.)
6
  • I didn't know that was possible to attack with terrain units directly from the ship. Thank you also for the other suggestions.
    – Drake
    Commented Sep 13, 2010 at 15:59
  • I didn't know that either, and I'd like someone to confirm that it is possible. Or is that a change in one of the extensions? Commented Sep 13, 2010 at 16:46
  • 2
    I will post screenshots tonight. (I have another reason for doing so anyway) Just in case, my answers are always from playing with Beyond The Sword, although very little of the core gameplay like this changed between vanilla/expansions. Commented Sep 13, 2010 at 17:06
  • 1
    Enjoy the screenshots. Note the correction: The effect is +50% for the defenders! Commented Sep 14, 2010 at 4:40
  • 1
    I'm pretty sure that in the base version only units with the amphibious upgrade can attack directly from boats. I can believe this was changed in BTS. Commented Jan 18, 2012 at 20:17

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .