I'm already in the Nightmare's Lair and I have an extra key in my inventory.

I checked the map and every square in it and I couldn't find anything that I may use the key for.

Is there a secret place or did I miss something along the way?


The extra key is a safeguard for earlier versions of the game where it was possible, through certain combinations, to incorrectly use your keys and make it impossible to finish the dungeon.

Key Cavern contains one more key than it does unlockable doors. The final Small Key in the dungeon drops from above automatically in the final room before the boss, when there is no use for it. If Link has not unlocked the optional rooms in this dungeon, it can be used to unlock them, although since both of them contain keys themselves and have no other purpose the end result will always leave Link with an extra key.

Source found on the Zelda Wiki


The key is a spare. You'll always have one extra if you explore the whole dungeon.

It's there because halfway through the dungeon, there is a branching pathway, with locked doors on all sides:

Key Cavern map segment

The right door takes you to the next part of the dungeon; all of the other doors are dead-ends with another key. There's nothing of value behind any of the doors other than some hearts (left), bombs (bottom), and the stone tablet/owl statue and crystal switch (top). The switch is useful if you want to go back and get the map or some Rupees, but it isn't required.

The extra key drops so you can go back and explore these rooms without being locked out forever. Since they all provide an extra key, though, you'll always have the spare.


It's been quite some time since I've played that game, but I'm rather sure that's intentional due to the nature of the dungeon offering you several locked paths at once. So depending on which route you take first (as far as I remember there are at least one or two paths being locked by two key blocks in succession), you could screw up otherwise. Although, to be honest, I don't remember having a leftover key (might depend on the effective route you take).


The final extra key is the “easter egg” for being named “Key Cavern”. Although the map is like a key.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy