I pre-ordered Fallout: New Vegas from GameStop and got the Classic Pack DLC as a "reward." I own a 360 Arcade and don't have an Xbox Live account. My girlfriend owns a 360 Elite and has a silver Live account.

Since I don't have Live, my girlfriend downloaded the Classic Pack to the Arcade. I started two games with Classic Pack items and they worked fine for a while. As far as I know, anyone can use DLC on the machine it's downloaded to first (in this case, the Arcade); only the downloader can use it on other machines (in this case, the Elite). Unfortunately, the Arcade red-ringed today; more specifically, it gave me the E74 error. (Details: go to the Xbox support website, click "one flashing light" and "error code E74.")

I figured, okay, no problem, I'll send the Arcade in for service — it's still covered by the E74 extended warranty — and use the Elite for now. But when I tried to load the game, I saw

"Some of your downloadable content is corrupt and could not be loaded."

And that's the story of how I found out that licenses are tied to specific consoles, not just Live accounts or hard drives. (Ref: Microsoft license transfer FAQ)

Now, I could just load my game and go, but I'm afraid of losing my items permanently because of the last issue I had. I could also use up the annual license transfer to move everything to the Elite, but that could have unintended consequences for other savegames; if not mine, then my girlfriend's. I'm also not even sure that will work; would the Elite become the new "first" machine, where anyone can use DLC? Or would there be no more "first" machine?

In short: is there anything I can do to play F:NV for the next three weeks that doesn't involve losing my Classic Pack items?


So here are the rules for DLC:

  • Anyone can play DLC on the Console on which it was purchased
  • The person who purchased the DLC can play it on any console

Now it seems like you already knew this part. However, there is a third rule!

  • Once per year you can move all your DLC to a new xbox! It is now considered to have been purchased on that xbox.

Using this magical third rule you (or your girlfriend) can recall all your DLC to a new box and anyone can play it on that box. It would become the "First" xbox in your example. This should not affect any saves on that box.

  • thanks! I didn't mention the third rule, but I did see it on the license transfer FAQ I linked. But as you say, it's only a once-a-year deal. The problem is that I don't want to be stuck using the Elite in three weeks when the repaired Arcade comes back from MS. Would this fall under the repair exemption? (Third item in this FAQ) +1 for your second-to-last sentence alone, though. – Pops Oct 26 '10 at 21:05
  • @Torgamus possibly, you'd have to phone MS to be sure. You can, however, always re-download to the arcade if only your account is going to use it on that system – tzenes Oct 27 '10 at 0:59
  • just for closure purposes: called Microsoft and got a long answer from the support guy. I asked him if his answer boiled down to "yes, but not really" and he said it did. So, no real answer there. – Pops Oct 28 '10 at 0:19
  • :( @Torgamus. I just reread your answer, and you said you don't have an account? Are you aware that a Silver, Xbox Live account is Free? That you can use said free account for purchasing DLC and the like? – tzenes Oct 28 '10 at 15:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.