I find that large fractions of my research times are spent trying to cope with planets striking due to obscene population disapproval, in the vicinity of 80% or more.

How does Expansion Disapproval work? A brief internet trawl claims that it's a factor directly on the size of your empire above two planets - does that mean that it's possible to have an empire so large that every single planet is on strike?! Or, are there particular actions that increase ED? (No jokes, please!) Does making colony ships from low-pop systems anger them? Does higher population placate them?

It just feels like I'm getting railroaded into a race for certain high-tier research because some of my systems are getting so angry about my expansion that they're starving themselves while striking. Lolwut.

2 Answers 2


There are three main ways to increase approval:

  1. Technologies that reduce expansion disapproval, in the Exploration/Expansion tree at the bottom. Each tech gives you -22% to the expansion disapproval. (Applied Casimir Effect gives you the Colonization Program, Applied Atmospherics gives you Orbital Counseling, etc.) These techs have a green star in the upper-right corner, which is no help at all because almost all of the Exploration/Expansion techs have that green star. You can't just search for "expansion disapproval" in the tech search box, either. The only hint I can give you is that most of these sorts of techs have an icon that includes a guy in a Buddha-like pose, except the first one.

  2. Technologies that increase approval in a system, in the Diplomacy/Trading tree on the left. These techs' icons are pink in the upper-right corner, and are a system improvement that gives a flat bonus to approval (and possibly other effects on FIDS) once built. The easiest-to-get examples: Botanical Scanning gives you Infinite Supermarkets for +25 approval, and Optimized Logistics gives you Colonial Rights for +30 approval (and some FIDS bonuses if they're ecstatic, around ~85% approval).

  3. Lower taxes; it's a slider in the Empire tab. Keep in mind that, aside from Dust generation and changing your Approval, some races get bonuses for high taxes (Humans get bonuses to both Dust and Industry as taxes go up), others get bonuses for low taxes (the Sophonts gain more research as taxes go down), and others don't care.

Low-approval penalties can hit you twice: once for low system approval, and again for low empire approval. Do not allow your entire empire to become unhappy with you; it's just ugly.

There are a few smaller things that change approval, but aren't universally useful:

  1. The less Earth-like the planet is, the more your colonists hate living there. Class V planets (gas giants, asteroids) hit you with -20 to approval; even Class II planets (like Tundra) give you -5.

  2. Heroes who are Administrators can grant approval bonuses, but you only have a few heroes.

  3. Some planetary anomalies will change approval, up or down. The approval penalties can go away by researching the anomaly-reduction technologies, Adaptive Colonies and Soil Revivification. Of course, you can't add anomalies to a planet, you're just stuck with whatever's there already.

  4. Two Endless Temples will increase approval in a system: the Temple of the Aura of Glory gives +40 approval to the system, and the Temple of Applied Psychohistorics gives +10 approval per planet in that system. You won't even know if you have a Temple until you do a Moon Survey (unlocked by Adaptive Colonies), and even then it will probably be a different Temple.

These are the only things that will give you approval. You will eventually need those techs. Higher population won't help - you'll lose some approval for overpopulation as your system fills up. From what I've researched on the 'net, expansion disapproval goes up as you add more systems, so settling a small number of systems with many planets might help.

Note: You only get the expansion disapproval once the system stops being an outpost, a few dozen turns after it's settled. Use that grace period to research some of those useful techs before your approval nosedives.

  • This might have changed since the Disharmony expansion, but I've definitely noticed outposts with low approval due to Expansion Disapproval.
    – toryan
    Commented Nov 11, 2013 at 22:24
  • 1
    @toryan Outposts can have expansion disapproval; they just don't cause expansion disapproval. So if you go on a colonization binge from your starting system and colonize 30 systems in 1 turn, then on the turn the outposts become colonies, you'll go from 0% expansion disapproval to all the expansion disapproval. (You'll also be broke from supporting 30 colonies for a few dozen turns from a single system, but that's a different issue.) Commented Nov 11, 2013 at 22:30
  • @PaulMarshall had to read that a couple of times before it made sense but thanks for the information ;)
    – toryan
    Commented Nov 12, 2013 at 0:37

Yes. Several techs in the left-hand section of the research web include improvements that reduce expansion disapproval. I'm not at a PC right now where I can play ES, so I'll add a list in a while -- if you're playing, all the happiness improvements are marked with a pink dot.

Edit: Oh, almost forgot -- certain leader traits can also increase happiness. This can be useful on getting new colonies out of that initial slump.

  • Ah. My title was misleading. I meant besides those researches. I'll go fix that.
    – rsegal
    Commented Dec 31, 2012 at 12:06
  • In that case, no -- but I've found that by the time that you've expanded to the point where expansion dissatisfaction becomes overwhelming, you also tend to have access to enough techs to kick happiness well into the upper ratings. Commented Dec 31, 2012 at 15:38
  • Well then I must be doing something different. By the time I have 15-20 planets, I'm totally hobbled by it, and haven't researched enough happiness factors.
    – rsegal
    Commented Jan 1, 2013 at 2:29

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .