2
Expanding Aequitas's answer there's also:
Garden Gnome: Increases Luck, effectively increasing damage inflicted and reducing received.
Bast Statue: Increases defense by 5.
1
While it will depend on your difficulty, equipment, and what you intend to do, Warding (+4 defense) and Menacing (+4% damage) are popular modifiers for all accessories that can be reforged.
In terms of what the game considers best, based on the effect of the modifier on the item's price, there's a 5-way tie:
Warding (+4 Defense)
Lucky (+4% Critical Strike ...
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible
Related Tags
terraria × 910terraria-mobile × 30
terraria-console × 18
steam × 16
technical-issues × 12
mods × 8
pc × 6
hosting × 5
achievements × 4
linux × 4
server-administration × 4
ps4 × 2
starbound × 2
keyboard × 2
ubuntu × 2
wine × 2
controllers × 1
xbox-one × 1
macos × 1
nintendo-3ds-3dsxl-2ds × 1
version-differences × 1
windows × 1
cheats × 1
networking × 1
mouse × 1