Does Doomcaller think my C'Thun is dead if I have multiple and only one is dead?

Question

Doomcaller is a card in the new Whispers of the Old Gods expansion, that reads "Give your C'Thun +2/+2 (wherever it is). If it's dead, shuffle it into your deck.".

This is a scenario that I will probably encounter soon: I play my C'Thun. It dies. My opponent plays C'Thun as well. I cast Entomb on it, which shuffles his C'Thun into my deck. Now I have a dead C'Thun, and another one in my deck.

If I play Doomcaller now, will it shuffle the dead one into my deck?

(similar situations occur with other cards, e.g. cards that make copies of C'Thun before it dies)

Answer 1

Yes, it will work.

Doomcaller just checks if C'Thun is dead, without caring about the presence of any other copy in your deck or hand.

A reddit user had a similar experience to the one you explained in your question: he got a C'Thun from A light in the darkness, played it and it subsequently died. After played a Doomcaller he got a second copy of C'Thun added to his deck.